Link

Social

Embed

Disable autoplay on embedded content?

Download

Download
Download Transcript

[00:06:50]

ONE MINUTE, METRO TV ONE MINUTE.

[Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance]

[00:07:27]

THE REGULAR LOUISVILLE METRO COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH. 14TH 2024 WILL PLEASE COME TO ORDER.

THE TIME IS CURRENTLY 6:03 P.M. PLEASE RISE FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE.

OF THE UNITED STATES. FOR WHICH IT STANDS. ONE NATION. INDI INDIVIDUALS. THIS MEETING IS BEING HELD PURSUANT TO KRS 61.826 AND COUNCIL RULE FIVE. A MADAM CLERK A ROLL CALL PLEASE.

[Member Roll Call]

COUNCIL MEMBER, HAWKINS COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN. PRESENT COUNCIL MEMBER PARISH RIGHT, PRESENT COUNCIL MEMBER ARTHUR COUNCIL MEMBER CURVES. COUNCIL MEMBER BAKER PRESIDENT O SORRY, MA'AM COUNCIL MEMBER MCCRANEY COUNCIL MEMBER RENO WEBER. COUNCIL MEMBER OWEN COUNCIL MEMBER OVER THE HILL HERE. COUNCIL MEMBER KRAMER COUNCIL MEMBER, BLACKWELL. COUNCIL MEMBERS COUNCIL MEMBER FOWLER COUNCIL MEMBER CHAPEL. COUNCIL MEMBER, REED PRESIDENT WINKLER COUNCIL MEMBER PARKER COUNCIL MEMBER PIACENTINI COUNCIL MEMBER BENSON COUNCIL MEMBER RUI HERE, COUNCIL MEMBER INGLE COUNCIL MEMBER HUDSON HERE, COUNCIL MEMBER F COUNCIL MEMBER BETS ON COUNCIL MEMBER ACKERSON. COUNCIL MEMBER RENA WEBER COUNCIL MEMBER, BLACKWELL COUNCIL MEMBER FOWLER. MR PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 23 AND DECORUM. THANK YOU. PLEASE LET THE RECORD REFLECT THAT. COUNCILMAN FOWLER HAS AN EXCUSED ABSENCE COUNCIL. RENO WEBER WILL BE JOINING US MOMENTARILY, AND I BELIEVE COUNCILMAN BLACKWELL IS THE OTHER PERSON MISSING THAT OVER HERE MOMENTARILY. COUNCILMAN ARTHUR I BELIEVE YOU HAVE A SPECIAL GUEST THIS EVENING? YES

[Introduction of Page(s)]

YES, YES, IT'S A BLESSING TO INTRODUCE TODAY'S PAGE FROM METRO COUNCIL DISTRICT FOUR.

SEAN COOKIE IS A SOPHOMORE AT THE CENTRAL HIGH AND IS IN THE ROTC. SEAN IS A COMMUNITY ACTIVIST AND TRAINING. HE ATTENDED HIS FIRST PROTEST RALLY AT AGE THREE AND CONTINUES TO ATTEND VARIOUS RALLIES TO THIS DAY, INCLUDING THE ONES AGAINST FAMILY DOLLAR SELLING ALCOHOL IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, HE VOLUNTEERS AT RUSSELL, A PLACE OF PROMISE EVENTS. HE ALSO VOLUNTEER. ON SEVERAL POLITICAL CAMPAIGNS BETWEEN ATTENDING SCHOOL RALLIES , VOLUNTEERING AND LEARNING THE HISTORY OF RUSSELL. SEAN SPENDS HIS FREE TIME BEING SPOILED BY HIS GRANDMOTHER, THE MAYOR OF THE RUSSELL NEIGHBORHOOD, MS JACKIE FLOYD. EVERYONE, PLEASE WELCOME ME. WELCOME THE PROUD

[00:10:08]

RUSSELL RESIDENT SEAN COOKSEY. SEAN, THANKS FOR BEING HERE. THANKS FOR BEING HERE.

COLLEAGUES BEFORE WE START TONIGHT'S MEETING. I WANT TO START BY TAKING A PERSONAL POINT OF PRIVILEGE AND THANKING COUNCILMAN MCCRANEY AND COUNCILMAN CHAPPELL, UH FOR A FANTASTIC WOMEN'S CAUCUS TODAY. IT REALLY WAS AN OUTSTANDING EVENT. UM, I ALSO WANT TO RECOGNIZE THE 10 OUTSTANDING WOMEN WHO WERE HONORED WITH THE ROSIE THE RIVETER AWARD, UM, FOR THEIR SIGN SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS TO LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY. UH, I'M SINCERELY GRATEFUL TO ALL OF YOU TO YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE. ALL OF THEM FOR THEIR SERVICE AND THANKFUL THAT THE WOMEN'S CAUCUS TOOK THE TIME TO MAKE SURE THAT THESE GREAT WOMEN WERE HIGHLIGHTED FOR WOMEN'S HISTORY MONTH. SO THANK YOU. GOT A COUPLE OF SPECIAL GUESTS THIS EVENING. UH, COUNCILMAN ACKERSON

[2. ID 24-0139     The Council will recognize Jeff Noble, District 26 Legislative Aide, in honor of his retirement. ]

, I BELIEVE YOU HAVE A SPECIAL GUEST THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO RECOGNIZE.

IS IT WORKING? THERE WE GO. I WOULDN'T CALL A SPECIAL GUEST FOLKS TONIGHT. I'M LOSING MY RIGHT ARM. UH, SOMEONE WHO'S BEEN TOO IMPORTANT FOR TOO LONG. WE'RE HERE TODAY TO RECOGNIZE SOMEBODY VERY SPECIAL TO ALL OF US. AND, UH, I USUALLY DON'T WRITE OUT THINGS. I USUALLY SPEAK FROM THE HEART AND SHOOT FROM THE HIP. BUT TONIGHT IT'S JUST TOO IMPORTANT. AND SO IF YOU'LL BEAR WITH ME, UH, TONIGHT. WE'RE HERE TO RECOGNIZE JEFFREY T NOBLE. JEFF HAS WORKED AS A DISTRICT 26 LEGISLATIVE ASSISTANT FOR ALMOST 16 YEARS NOW. HE AND I CAME TO CITY HALL TOGETHER. STARTED THIS JOURNEY TOGETHER. AFTER NEARLY 16 YEARS, HE'S DECIDED TO RETIRE EARLY AND GO ON TO OTHER ADVENTURES AND TRAVELS FOR THAT. I'M BOTH HAPPY FOR HIM AND ANGRY WITH HIM. THE ANGRY PARTS OF MY OWN SELFISHNESS, AND I SPEAK ON THE BEHALF OF THE RESIDENTS OF DISTRICT 26 WHO ARE VERY UPSET WITH YOU LEAVING ALSO UH, TODAY ON BOTH SADDENED THAT HE WILL NO LONGER BE HERE ON THIS JOURNEY WITH ME. BUT IT MAKES ME HAPPY THAT HE'S CHOSEN TO FREE UP MORE OF HIS TIME TO GO AND TAKE A BIGGER BITE OUT OF THE APPLE OF LIFE. I'VE NEVER CONSIDERED JEFF, MY EMPLOYEE. HE'S BEEN MY ADVISER, MY OFFICE COLLEAGUE AND MY FRIEND. HE'S BEEN A STRONG AND STEADY ADVOCATE FOR THE PEOPLE OF THE 26 COUNCIL DISTRICT. AND IN REALITY. HE WOULD HAVE MADE A MUCH BETTER COUNCIL PERSON THAN THAN ME. IT IS TRUE. WHEN I WHEN I SAY IT, IT'S TRUE. YES, HIS POLITICS ARE STRONG TO THE LEFT. BUT THE REALITY IS HE'S LOVED BY DEMOCRATS. HE'S LOVED BY REPUBLICANS, AND HE'S LOVED BY INDEPENDENTS. IT'S ALL BECAUSE OF HIS EXTENSIVE KNOWLEDGE, ESPECIALLY IN POLITICS. HIS PASSION TO MAKE THE LIVES OF OTHERS BETTER. AND IN FACT, JEFF'S COMPASSION AND HELPFULNESS OFTEN COMES AS A FAULT TO HIMSELF. LONG BEFORE METRO COUNCIL, JEFF HAD A ROLE IN DEMOCRATIC POLITICS DECADES AGO AS A YOUNG MAN AT THE UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY, HE TOOK AN ACTIVE ROLE IN VARIOUS FORMS OF STUDENT GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS IN GENERAL. HE WAS THINNER THAN HE HAD A FULL HEAD OF BLACK CURLY HAIR, ALMOST THE HAIR THAT EVEN THE BIBLICAL SAMPSON WOULD HAVE BEEN JEALOUS AND ENVIOUS OF HE STILL CARRIES AROUND AN ID FROM THOSE DAYS. LONGING FOR THE DAYS OF THOSE LOCKS TO COME BACK. OVER THE DECADES, JEFF HAS SERVED AS A DEMOCRATIC POLITICAL ADVISER AND CAMPAIGN CONSULTANTS FROM GOVERNORS TO STATE SENATORS TO STATE REPRESENTATIVES, LOCAL OFFICIALS, MAYORS AND EVEN CONGRESSMAN YARMOUTH. HE HAS SERVED THE LOCAL PARTY AND THE STATE PARTY FOR DECADES, INTERPRETING RULES AND BYLAWS AND ARGUING FOR WHAT HE SAW AS JUSTIN, RIGHT. EVEN IN LIGHT OF MAKING THOSE IN POWER MAD. JEFF KNOWS ABOUT EVERYONE IN POLITICS. AND COULD TELL YOU PERSONAL STORIES GOING BACK 30 YEARS OF VARIOUS STATE LOCAL OFFICIALS, THEIR QUIRKS. THEY'RE ANIMATED CHARACTERISTICS. AND EVEN THEIR PERSONAL FLAWS AND VICES. WITH ALL THIS KNOWLEDGE, HE COULD WRITE A HELL OF A COMEDIC AND ENTERTAINING NOVEL.

[00:15:02]

AND MY ONLY HOPE WAS THAT SOMEDAY MAYBE I'LL MAKE A FOOTNOTE. SOME CHAPTER. HE'S BEEN A MATHEMATICS SAVANT WHEN IT COMES TO ELECTION RESULTS AND TARGETING ELECTIONEERING. JUST AS RAIN MAN COULD COUNT TOOTHPICKS AND BLACKJACK CARDS. JEFF NOBLE CAN COUNT VOTES. IN 2008 WHILE WORKING FOR THE FIRST YARMOUTH FOR CONGRESS CAMPAIGN, HE PREDICTED JOHN'S ELECTION RESULTS THE WINNING NUMBERS WITHIN A FEW 100 VOTES OF THE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS CAST IN JEFFERSON COUNTY. IT HAS BEEN HIS KNOWLEDGE AND BUILD WITH NUMBERS THAT HAS CAUSED THE METRO COUNCIL TO RELY UPON HIM TO REDRAW COUNCIL DISTRICTS, BOTH IN 2011 2021. BECAUSE OF THE CHANGING CENSUS POPULATION NUMBERS. NOT TOO LONG AGO, THE KENTUCKY DEMOCRATIC STATE SENATE CAUCUS CONSULTED WITH HIM ON REDRAWING THEIR STATE SENATE DISTRICTS. JEFF NOBLE IS NO ORDINARY OR SIMPLE MAN. HE'S THE POWERFUL AND KNOWLEDGEABLE PERSON WHO OFTEN STANDS QUIETLY TO THE SIDE OF THE ROOM. LESS FOCUSED ON MAKING HIMSELF KNOWN AND MORE FOCUSED ON ABSORBING WHAT IS GOING ON AROUND HIM. AND PREPARED TO LEND ASSISTANCE FOR ANYONE WHO NEEDED HIS KNOWLEDGE OR ADVICE. AT CITY HALL. YOU ALL KNOW ALL OF YOU IN THIS ROOM AND THOSE WHO ARE ON THIS ROOM, YOU ALL KNOW THAT YOU HAVE TURNED TO JEFF. FOR CONSULT AND ADVICE. YOU KNOW THAT YOU HAVE TURNED TO JEFF FOR ITS EXTENSIVE HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL KNOWLEDGE. YOU KNOW THAT YOU HAVE TURNED TO JEFF FOR HIS BIG HEART. HIS KINDNESS, HIS THOUGHTFUL WORDS AND HIS FRIENDSHIP. TODAY IS A SAD DAY AND THAT WE ARE LOSING HIM TO NEWER AND BIGGER VENTURE. BUT IT'S A HAPPY DAY. AND THAT WE KNOW THAT THERE ARE GREAT THINGS AND GREAT POSSIBILITIES THAT LAY WAITING FOR HIM. JEFF. I KNOW I SPEAK FOR EVERYONE IN THIS ROOM. WHEN I SAY GREAT SUCCESS FOR THINGS TO COME. AND GOD SPEED, MY FRIEND. I WILL MISS SEEING YOU AND SPEAKING WITH YOU ON A DAILY BASIS. BUT I'M EXCITED FOR WHAT'S TO COME. AT THE END OF THE DAY. I WILL MISS MY FRIEND.

THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN. UH, WE HAVE A PROCLAMATION THAT I WILL READ INTO THE RECORD, UH, TO ALL WHOM THESE LETTERS SHALL COME. GREETINGS KNOW YE THAT LOUISVILLE METRO COUNCIL IN SPIRIT OF DEEP GRATITUDE HONORS JEFFREY T NOBLE. WHERE HAS HE IS HONORABLY SERVED AS LOUISVILLE METRO COUNCIL DISTRICT 26, LEGISLATIVE ASSISTANT TO COUNCILMAN BRENT ACKERSON FOR OVER 15 YEARS FROM JANUARY, 2009 TO MARCH 2024. AND WHEREAS HIS LOVE AND COMMITMENT OF LOUISVILLE SHINES THROUGH HIS EFFORTS ON COUNCIL AND IN POLITICS, AND WHEREAS THROUGH HIS YEARS OF SERVICE WORKING WITH COUNCILMAN ACKERSON, HE EFFECTUATED CRITICAL IMPROVEMENTS TO THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND INFRASTRUCTURE IN DISTRICT 26, INCLUDING THE TRANSFORMATION OF PEE WEE PARK, LEADING THE INSTALLATION OF THE FIRST PICKLEBALL COURT IN JEFFERSON COUNTY, RE ENVISIONING AND REINVESTING INTO FARNSLEY PARK, AGGRESSIVELY PRIORITIZING STREET PAVING AND SIDEWALK REPLACEMENT, INCLUDING THE $7 MILLION HIKES, LANE REHABILITATION AND REPAVING PROJECT. ADDRESSING MS D CONCERNS UNTIL 2 A.M. IN THE MORNING ON BRECKENRIDGE LANE, CONNECTING WITH CONSTITUENTS THROUGH TOWN HALL MEETINGS, SERVING AS THE LIAISON BETWEEN NEIGHBORS AND NEIGHBORHOOD GROUPS WITH METRO GOVERNMENT AND SMALL CITIES AND VISITING CONSTITUENTS HOMES TO RESOLVE CONTENTIONS AND CONFLICTS, WHEREAS THE COUNCIL RECOGNIZES HIS INTEGRAL SERVICE REDISTRICTING, THE LOUIS METRO COUNCIL'S 26 DISTRICTS IN 2011 AND 2021 AND REAPPORTIONING THE COUNTY COMMISSIONER'S DISTRICTS ON THE REAPPORTIONMENT COMMISSION IN 2011 AND 2023, AND WHEREAS WE THANK HIM FOR HIS ENCYCLOPEDIC HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL KNOWLEDGE, HIS GUIDANCE AND FRIENDSHIP TO THE MYRIAD OF COUNCIL MEMBERS, LEGISLATIVE ASSISTANCE CLERKS AND CAUCUS STAFF THAT HAVE HAD THE HONOR OF SHA THESE HALLOWED HALLS WITH HIM NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE LOUISVILLE METRO COUNCIL WE HEREBY CONFIRM AND PAY TRIBUTE BY WAY OF THIS PROCLAMATION WITH ALL RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES AND RESPONSIBILITIES, THEREUNTO APPERTAINING IN TESTIMONY WE HAVE CAUSED THESE LETTERS TO BE MADE IN THE SEAL OF METRO GOVERNMENT TO BE HERE UNTO AFFIXED LOUIS METRO CITY HALL THIS DAY 2024. THANK YOU, MICHAEL. UH, YEAH, I KNOW. JEFF, WE'RE GONNA HAVE YOU SPEAK, AND THEN I'M SURE THERE'S OTHER PEOPLE THAT WANT TO SPEAK AS WELL. I BEFORE YOU I DID JUST WANT TO SAY I HAD THINGS I WANTED TO SAY, BUT I DO NOT DARE FOLLOW. UH, WHAT I WOULD SAY IS ONE OF PROBABLY THE BEST SEND OFF SPEECHES. I'VE HEARD COUNCILMAN ACKERSON. IT WAS BEAUTIFULLY BEAUTIFULLY SAID, AND, UM JEFF, YOU WOULD BE GREATLY MISSED. SO THE FLOOR IS YOURS. WELL. UM THANK YOU. THAT'S I'M A LITTLE STUNNED AND A LITTLE SPEECHLESS. UM SO I

[00:20:08]

WROTE THINGS. UM, THANK YOU, BRENT AND MICHAEL AND MIGUEL. UH, AS MOST OF YOU ALL KNOW, I LIKE TO TELL STORIES. I'LL TRY TO KEEP THIS ONE SHORT, ALTHOUGH I DON'T KNOW THAT I CAN ONE OF MY FAVORITE SONGS IS JOHN MELLENCAMP'S SMALL TOWN. SOME OF THE LYRICS FROM THAT SONG YOU PROBABLY KNOW ARE I WAS BORN IN A SMALL TOWN PROBABLY DIE IN A SMALL TOWN. OUR PARENTS LIVE IN THE SAME SMALL TOWN. MY JOB IS SO SMALL TOWN, BUT I'VE SEEN IT ALL IN A SMALL TOWN. THAT'S LAW, WHERE, DESPITE THE EFFORTS OF MANY MAYBE SOME OF YOU WE'RE JUST A BIG SMALL TOWN. ONE OF MY POLITICAL MENTORS IS JIM MCGOVERN, WHO OFTEN REMINDS ME THAT THERE ARE USUALLY ONLY TWO DEGREES OF SEPARATION BETWEEN MOST OF THE BILLIONS. LET ME EXPLAIN. I FIRST CAME TO THIS BUILDING WITH MY UNCLE, DON NOBLE. THE FORMER ALDERMAN IN APRIL, 1977. TO THIS VERY ROOM.

MY UNCLE DON WAS HELPING THE UNCLE OF A FRIEND OF MINE IN A POLITICAL CAMPAIGN. ONE THAT WAS TRYING TO UNSEAT A MARY MOBILE COUNCILMAN MOBILE'S MOTHER. ALSO WITH US THAT NIGHT WAS JIM TO AND HIS SON, GRAN. FIVE YEARS LATER, I WENT TO WORK FOR THAT UNCLE OF MY FRIEND WHEN HE WAS ELECTED, SERVING AS A LEGISLATIVE AIDE SEATED PRETTY CLOSE TO WHERE WE ALL ARE NOW.

THAT WAS 42 YEARS AGO. ONE OF MY FELLOW LEGISLATIVE AIDES, MR DOLORES TRIPLETT, WHO WAS THE MOTHER OF FORMER COUNCILMAN KEVIN TRIPLETT. I DIDN'T LAST VERY LONG HERE. I WORKED FOR SEVERAL ALDERMEN. BEFORE MOVING TO THE PRIVATE SECTOR, WHERE I WORKED AS A PARALEGAL AND TITLE CLERK FOR A NUMBER OF ATTORNEYS FOR THE NEXT 16 YEARS. PRIMARILY FOR JAY BRUCE MILLER, WHO I HAPPEN TO SEE EARLIER TODAY OVER AT FOURTH AND MAINE, AND WE GOT A VERY NICE CONVERSATION. IN 1998. I BECAME INVOLVED IN WHAT TURNED OUT TO BE THE LAST RACE FOR MAYOR OF THE CITY OF LOUISVILLE, A PART OF THE LEADERSHIP TEAM OF THE TOM OWEN FOR MAYOR CAMPAIGN. BY THE WAY, ONE OF MY COWORKERS IN THAT CAMPAIGN WAS KEN HERNAN, WHO I SEE OVER THERE IN THAT CORNER RIGHT THERE. DOCTOR OWEN BEING THE FATHER OF COUNCILMAN ANDREW OWEN. THE NEXT YEAR IN JANUARY OF 1999. I WAS SITTING UP THERE IN ONE OF THOSE BIG CHAIRS WHERE KYLE IS RIGHT NOW. THE NIGHT THE BOARD OF ALDERMEN FINALLY FINALLY PASSED THE FAIRNESS AMENDMENT TO THE CODE OF ORDINANCES. I HAPPENED TO BE SITTING THERE BECAUSE I WAS BEING APPOINTED THAT NIGHT AS A COMMISSIONER TO THE REVENUE COMMISSION. REPRESENTING THE BOARD OF ALDERMEN. MY COUNTERPART FROM THE FISCAL COURT WAS BETH STENBERG. HE THEN COUNTY TREASURER. THE CHAIR OF THE REVENUE COMMISSION. AT THE TIME WAS A GUY. MY FATHER HAD GONE TO PLEDGE A HIGH SCHOOL WITH RAY CRITTER WHO WAS THE FATHER OF COUNCILMAN FLOODS. LEGISLATIVE AIDE ANDREA DARWIN.

FOLLOWING THE APPROVAL OF THE VOTERS OF MERGER. AND I VOTED NO ON MERGER. AND I SAY THAT EVERY SINGLE TIME I MENTION IT. I DECIDED TO RUN FOR ONE OF THE NEW SEATS. I ENTERED A DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY WITH EIGHT OTHER CANDIDATES, AND ALTHOUGH I WON SIX PRECINCTS, I RAN THIRD AMONG THE NINE CANDIDATES IN THAT DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY AND AT THE END OF ELECTION DAY. I MET THE WINNER. OF THAT RACE THAT THOMAS JEFFERSON MIDDLE SCHOOL, ONE OF THE POLLING PLACES AND CONGRATULATED HER ON HER WIN AND PLEDGED TO SUPPORT HER IN HER WORK IN HER DISTRICT, AND I'M VERY PLEASED TO SAY WE'RE STILL FRIENDS AND I'M STILL SUPPORTING DOCTOR SHANKLIN IN HER WORK IN THE SECOND COUNCIL DISTRICT. FINALLY WHILE WORKING IN ANOTHER CAMPAIGN IN 2006. I CAME ACROSS THIS GUY GN AKERSON. HE WAS RUNNING HIS OWN COUNTYWIDE CAMPAIGN THAT YEAR. EVERYWHERE WE GO. HE WAS THERE OFTEN WITH HIS THEN VERY YOUNG SON HUSTLING FOR BOATS. THE NEXT YEAR. I WAS SOMEWHAT FORMALLY, IF VERY QUICKLY INTRODUCED TO HIM IN THE COURTHOUSE ALLEY BEHIND METRO HALL BY TWO VERY LONGTIME FRIENDS, BRENT WAS SCURRYING THROUGH AS HE OFTEN DOES ON HIS WAY TO COURT STOPPING BRIEFLY TO SPEAK. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU REMEMBER THIS OR NOT. THE OTHER TWO WHO INTRODUCED US. THEY LATER TOLD ME THEY WERE HOPING HE WOULD RUN FOR COUNCIL IN 2008. ONE OF THOSE GUYS WITH SHERMAN BROWN, WHO'S NOW A LOBBYIST, AND THE OTHER WAS HIS FORMER NEIGHBOR, AND HE WAS SHEER LATER THAT YEAR, SHERMAN AND GREG REDDINGTON IT WAS ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO I WAS WITH THAT FIRST NIGHT. I WAS HERE IN 1977. CALLED ME TO A MEETING.

[00:25:02]

THEY ASKED ME TO GET INVOLVED IN BRENT'S FUTURE COUNSEL RACE. AND THAT MEETING BROUGHT ME HERE TO THIS MEETING TODAY. THE END OF A GREAT AND REWARDING 15 YEAR COLLABORATION. DURING THOSE 15 YEARS, I'VE SEEN THE ELECTION. AND A FEW DEFEATS OF SEVERAL FRIENDS TO THIS BODY. OF THE 26 OF YOU. I'VE KNOWN COUNCILMAN MULVIHILL, THE LONGEST SINCE THE VERY EARLY 19 EIGHTIES, AND I'M GRATEFUL TO HAVE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY. TO WATCH YOU AND YOUR POLITICAL LIFE AND BECOME A SUPPORTER OF YOURS. I'M VERY PROUD OF YOU. I REALLY AM. I WATCHED YOU GROW UP AND IT'S PRETTY COOL. COUNCILMAN PLIED REPRESENTS THE AREA WHERE I WAS RAISED AND WHERE MY MOTHER STILL LIVES. I HELPED YOU IN YOUR FIRST RACE, WE WALKED DOWN BOSTON LANE TOGETHER WITH MAYOR ABRAMSON AND RON WESTON. I WANNA THANK YOU FOR YOUR YEARS ON THE COUNCIL AND WHAT YOU'VE DONE HERE. AS YOU KNOW, PLANNING AND ZONING IS SOMETHING VERY DEAR TO MY HEART. YOU'VE DONE AN EXCELLENT JOB WITH THAT. OF THE GOP MEMBERS. I APPRECIATE THE REGULAR QUESTIONING THE COUNCILMAN KRAMER DOES. I REALLY DO. YOU OFTEN ASK, AND I'VE TOLD YOU THIS BEFORE. YOU OFTEN ASK THE QUESTIONS THAT I WOULD KIND OF QUIETLY WENT TO ASK MANY OF YOU AND I APPRECIATIVE OF YOU DOING THAT. COUNCIL MURS YOU WILL NEVER KNOW THE EMOTIONAL IMPACT YOU HAD ON THE WHEN YOU TOLD ME OF YOUR VISIT AND PRAYERS. WHAT? I WAS HOSPITALIZED. IN 2005. NOT EVER, REALLY KNOWING WHO I WAS. I APPRECIATE THAT. I'VE ALREADY MENTIONED COUNCILMAN SHANKLIN. I DON'T KNOW IF SHE'S ONLINE OR NOT. I CONSIDER HER A FRIEND, A MENTOR AND A LEADER FOR THIS COUNCIL, AND I THANK YOU, DOCTOR SHANKLIN FOR YOUR YEARS OF SERVICE AND OUR YEARS OF FRIENDSHIP. FOR ALL OF THIS. I HAVE BRENT, HIS WIFE, TAMMY. AND THE CONSTITUENTS OF THE 26 DISTRICT TO THANK THE OTHER LYRICS OF MELLENCAMP'S SMALL TOWN INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING I HAD MYSELF A BALL IN A SMALL TOWN. I CANNOT FORGET THE PEOPLE WHO LOVE ME. I CANNOT BE MY I CAN BE MYSELF HERE IN THIS SMALL TOWN. AND PEOPLE JUST LET ME BE WHAT I WANT TO BE. THANK YOU, BRENT.

AND THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT.

JEFF I SAID THIS. I SAID THIS EARLIER DOWNSTAIRS AT YOUR RECEPTION. I'LL SAY IT AGAIN. I THANK YOU FOR YOUR 25 YEARS OF DEDICATED SERVICE TO THE CITY. YOU KNOW IT IS. YOUR WORK BEHIND THE SCENES THAT HELPS KEEP GOVERNMENT RUNNING AND YOU ARE, AS COUNCILMAN ACKER HAD SAID. I MEAN, EIGHT. BRILLIANT THINKER. UH A KIND HUMAN BEING, UM AND YOU WILL LEAVE AN ENORMOUS HOLE.

UM HERE AND YOU WILL BE GREATLY MISSED. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR PIACENTINI. THANK THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. JUST REAL QUICK. UH UH. I. I DIDN'T GROW UP HERE, BUT I WAS BORN IN 1977. SO THERE'S A CONNECTION FROM WHEN YOU FIRST WALKED IN THIS BUILDING. INDEED, KINDNESS WILL BE A WORD THAT'S ALREADY BEEN SAID SO MANY TIMES. I'M GONNA MISS, UH, STOPPING IN THAT OFFICE, UH, COMING IN AND OUT OF CHAMBERS AND SEEING YOU AND YOU'RE BY FAR ONE OF THE KINDEST MEN HERE, UH, I. I WANNA TALK ABOUT, UM, SOME OF THE PEOPLE I RESPECT THE MOST AND HAVE DIFFERENT SIDES OF THE POLITICAL UH, BUT I RESPECT UM, EVERYBODY, AND THIS IS FOR ANYBODY THAT WANTS TO GET INVOLVED IN IN LOCAL POLITICS. UM, IT'S PEOPLE LIKE JEFF THAT TO PRESIDENT WINKLER'S POINT MAKE THIS WORK. AND HAVE DEDICATED YOUR ENTIRE LIFE OR A LARGE CHUNK OF IT TO THIS, AND YOUR TIME OFF IS WELL DESERVED. AND I WANT TO TELL YOU MUCH RESPECT YOU AND THE WORK YOU'VE DONE AND I. I WANNA SPECIFICALLY THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK IN REDISTRICTING. UH IT WAS BOTH ONE OF THE HONORS OF THE TIME THAT I'VE BEEN IN OFFICE TO WORK WITH COUNCILMAN WINKLER AS CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE WHEN WE WERE CAUCUS, UH, CHAIRS TO DO REDISTRICTING AND THAT AS HARD AS THAT WAS IT WOULD HAVE BEEN IMPOSSIBLE WITHOUT YOU. AND I JUST WANTED TO THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THAT. THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR KREN.

THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. JEFF, I JUST HAVE ONE QUESTION FOR YOU. ACTUALLY I DON'T. UM BUT I DO WANNA SAY IN IN BRENT'S, UH, COMMENTS. HE MENTIONED THAT, UM, THAT THE RESIDENTS OF DISTRICT SIX WOULD MISS YOU ALMOST AS MUCH AS HE WOULD. UM, AND I HAVE TO SAY THAT 26. I'M SORRY. THE

[00:30:06]

RESIDENTS OF DISTRICT 26 6 AS WELL, UM, BUT BUT FOR THE RECORD , UM I'VE BEEN THROUGH TWO DIFFERENT REDISTRICTS AND BOTH TIMES, UM I LOST CONSTITUENTS TO COUNCILMAN ACKERSON. UM, I CAN I CAN SAFELY SAY THAT THERE ARE CONSTITUENTS THAT ARE IN DISTRICT 26 THAT WERE IN DISTRICT 11. THAT WILL MISS YOU TERRIBLY. UM, I'M REALLY GRATEFUL FOR THE RELATIONSHIP THAT OUR OFFICES HAVE HAD OVER THOSE NUMBER OF YEARS WHEN NEITHER ONE OF US IS REALLY CARED VERY MUCH WHERE THE LINES WERE THAT SEPARATED 2611. WE JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT THE FOLKS WHO LIVE THERE GOT TAKEN CARE OF, AND THAT IS LARGELY BECAUSE OF YOUR EFFORT AT REPRESENT AT TAKING CARE OF EVERYBODY IN YOUR DISTRICT. EVEN THE NEW FOLKS, SO THANK YOU FOR ALL THAT YOU DID, AND I YOU. THE FOLKS THAT USED TO BE AN 11 WILL MISS YOU AS MUCH AS THE REST OF YOUR DISTRICT. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR. THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN SHANKLIN. JEFF I'M SO SORRY I NOT THERE. BUT I REMEMBER THE FIRST DAY I MET YOU IS AFTER THE RACE WAS OVER. YOU CAME TO MY OFFICE AND YOU GAVE ME ALL THE BOTH THE OTHER AND EVERYTHING YOU HAVE. AND YOU SAID, I'LL ALWAYS HELP YOU. AND YOU HAVE DONE THAT. SO I'M GONNA MAKE SURE I STILL HAVE YOUR PHONE NUMBER. SO IT AIN'T YOU DON'T GET RID OF ME JUST LIKE THAT. SO TAKE THE CITY, THOUGH. BUT I WILL BE TALKING TO YOU. THANKS. YES, MA'AM. COUNCIL MCCRANEY THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. JEFF, I KNOW YOU WON'T BE FAR AWAY. AND YOU CAN RUN BUT YOU CANNOT HIDE. AND I CAN TELL YOU THAT I AM ONLY HERE BECAUSE OF YOU. AND YOU KNOW THE STORY. YOU KNOW THE BACK STORY, BUT I APPRECIATE YOU FOR THE ADVICE YOU'VE GIVEN ME. I APPRECIATE YOU AND YOUR KNOWLEDGE, YOUR INSTITUTIONAL KNOWLEDGE AND YOUR STORIES. AND I WILL CONTINUE TO FOLLOW YOU ON FACEBOOK TO SEE WHERE YOU WHERE YOUR HEART IS BECAUSE YOU TELL IT IN GOOD STORIES. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU'VE DONE FOR ME. I ABSOLUTELY OWE THIS SEAT TO YOU. BEST WISHES COUNCIL FLOOD THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT.

JEFF, YOU'RE ONE OF THE PEOPLE DOWN HERE THAT I CAN SAY, UH, KNEW MY HUSBAND LONGER THAN I HAVE. BUT I WANNA THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR YOUR HELP YOUR ADVICE OVER THE YEARS, WHETHER IT'S POLITICAL OR IF IT'S SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE OFFICE AND FOR ALWAYS, NEVER BEING TOO BUSY TO TAKE MY CALL. YOU ARE SO APPRECIATED BY MANY DOWN HERE, AS YOU CAN SEE, TONIGHT, WE'RE GONNA MISS YOU. LOOK FORWARD TO RUNNING INTO YOU OUT IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. COUNCILMAN PER JENNIFER, I JUST WANNA SAY THAT I REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR FRIENDSHIP. UM YOU ADD SUCH A VALUE TO ALL 26 COUNCIL MEMBERS, NO MATTER WHAT THE PARTY IS. AND I REMEMBER WHEN I FIRST MET YOU, EVERYBODY WAS FIGHTING FOR YOU TO BE ON THE JEOPARDY TEAM BECAUSE YOU KNEW ALL THE ANSWERS. AND IT IS TRUE I'VE SEEN YOU KNOW ALL THE ANSWERS IN EVERY ASPECT OF LIFE.

AND I TRULY TRULY APPRECIATE YOU . AND I JUST WANNA SAY THANK YOU FOR BEING MY FRIEND. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, COUNCILOR MO MO THANK YOU AND JEFF. THANKS FOR YOUR KIND WORDS. I KNOW WE'VE ALWAYS SEEM TO BE ON THE OPPOSITE ENDS ON ELECTIONS AND CAMPAIGNS, BUT, UH, THROUGH IT ALL, WE'VE ALWAYS REMAINED FRIENDS AND I'VE ALWAYS APPRECIATED YOUR SUPPORT YOUR CANDOR AND HONESTY. UH, IT'S NOT ALWAYS WHAT I WANNA HEAR. BUT I'VE ALWAYS APPRECIATED AND THAT'S WHAT YOU GET. THAT'S ALL YOU CAN EXPECT OUT OF SOMEBODY. AND I WISH YOU ALL THE BEST. AND UH, THANKS FOR ALWAYS BEING MY FRIEND. AND THANKS FOR YOUR SUPPORT OVER THE YEARS TAKE CARE. THANK YOU, PAT. THANK YOU.

BEST WISHES IN YOUR NEXT ENDEAVORS, AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU AGAIN. VERY GOOD.

THANK YOU. COUNCILMAN BAKER. I BELIEVE YOU HAVE A SPECIAL GUEST.

YEAH, OKAY. WE ARE OK. ALL RIGHT. UH THANK YOU. UH, MR. UH UH, PRESIDENT FOR BEING ABLE A CHANCE TO DO THIS. UH, AND ALSO BEFORE I BEGIN, I WANNA THANK JEFF AS WELL, UH, FOR EVERYTHING HE'S DONE, EVEN FOR THE NEWBIE. SO EVEN THOUGH HE'S TAKING CARE OF ALL UOGS, HE MAKES SURE HE IS BEEN VERY KIND AND BEEN ABLE TO SAY HE'S BEEN A WEALTH OF INFORMATION AND A WEALTH OF HEALTH. SO THANK YOU, UH TO, UM JEFF FOR EVERYTHING HE'S DONE, UH, FOR MY LIFE AS WELL, BUT WITH THAT BEING SAID I WANNA DO, UH, A PROCLAMATION TODAY. UH,

[00:35:02]

THE WOMEN'S CAUCUS SHOWED UP AND SHOWED OUT, COUNCILWOMAN, UH, MCCRANEY COUNCIL. JUST EVERYBODY . YOU ALL HAD A PHENOMENAL PROGRAM. AND IN THAT PROGRAM, WE HAD THE PHENOMENAL VALERIE COMBS AND VALERIE COMBS. FOR THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW. I DON'T KNOW. IF WE HAVE ANY U OF L FANS. IT'S GOING TO BE OK, Y'ALL. UM, BUT THE 1ST 1000 POINT SCORE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE WAS MS VALERIE COMBS. AND IF YOU ATTENDED THE WOMEN'S CAUCUS, AND YOU WERE AT THE PROGRAM, YOU SAW A WOMAN AFTER WOMAN AFTER WOMAN WHO WERE QUEENS AND CHAMPIONS AND JUST ARE REALLY THE PILLARS WHO HOLD UP OUR COMMUNITY AND NOT TO STILL THE SHINE. I SAID, IF I CAN'T GET YOU KNOW, MISS VALERIE, WHO'S THE NEXT PERSON? ANOTHER QUEEN AND CHAMPION OF HER OWN RIGHT? AND THAT IS HER DAUGHTER, GIOVANNI COS. A KAG COMBS WHO A LOT OF PEOPLE DO NOT KNOW THIS, BUT SHE WON. WHEN I MET HER. SHE DOES A LOT OF SERVICE WORK. SHE'S BEEN IN SCHOOLS SHE'S BEEN DOING, UH, TEACHING YOUNG GIRLS. SHE'S BEEN MOVING AND SHAKING, LIKE A LOT OF THE QUEENS THAT WERE, UH, PRESENTED TODAY, YOU KNOW, JUST PHENOMENAL AND BUT SHE IS MISS COSMO USA, AND THAT IS A REAL GROUND. AND THAT IS AND THAT IS THAT IS NO SMALL FEAT. AND SO WITH THAT I WOULD LIKE TO WITH FROM DISTRICT SIX, WHICH U OF L SHARES BETWEEN MY OFFICE AND COUNCILWOMAN CHAPPELL BE ABLE TO HONOR YOU AND HAVE THE PLEASURE OF BEING ABLE TO PRESENT YOU IN AN HONORARY MEMBER OF YOUR MOTHER A PROCLAMATION. BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY, UGF SO IT READS AS SUCH TO ALL WHOM THESE PRESENTS SHALL COME. GREETINGS KNOW YE THAT THE LOUIS METRO COUNCIL HEREBY HONORS GIOVANNA COMBS, WHEREAS MISS COMBS, A GRADUATE OF DISTRICT SIX, DUPONT MANUAL, HIGH SCHOOL AND THE UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE HAS SERVED THE COMMUNITY THROUGH MY SPECIAL PROJECTS, INCLUDING ROOTS RESOURCESUT OF THECHOO, WHIC IS SIGN TO STRENGEN THE COMMUNITY AND OFFER MORE TO OUYOST. D RBYCCESSIBLE. ALSONNTUCKY DISTRICT SIX ROYAL COURT AND THIS PAST AUGUST, MISS COS. WAS HONORED AS MISS COSMO UNITED STATES REPRESENTING KENTUCKY.

AND WHEREAS MS COMBS OUTSTANDING , UNWAVERING COMMITMENT TO SERVING OTHERS HAS WOVEN A TAPESTRY OF COMPASSION AND SUPPORT THROUGH OUR NEIGHBORHOODS, HER BALANCED EN ENERGY AND PASSION RIPPLE THROUGH OUR COMMUNITY, LEAVE IT BEHIND A LEGACY OF KINDNESS AND EMPOWERMENT WITH HUMITY GRACE. SHE REMINDS US THE TRUE MEASURE OF A PERSONALIZING THEIR ABILITY TO MAKE A POSITIVE IMPACT IN THE LIVES OF OTHERS. SO WE HEAR BACK AND FOR THIS HONOR WITH ALL RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES AND RESP RESPONSIBILITY, THERE ARE TWO APPERTAINING AND TESTING WHERE, UH, CALL THESE LETTERS AND YOU MAKE PATENT IN THE OFFICIAL SEAL OF LOUISVILLE, JEFFERSON COUNTY METRO GOVERNMENT THIS DAY, UH, MARCH 14TH IN THE YEAR OF 2024.

THANK YOU. AND IF YOU HAVE A FEW WORDS, GIVE HER A HAND. OK? AND IF YOU HAVE A FEW WORDS YOU LOVE THAT. UH LET ME START BY SAYING THANK YOU ALL FOR WELCOMING ME INTO THIS SPACE TODAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. COUNCILMAN BAKER FOR THIS PROCLAMATION. UM HONESTLY, I WOULD NOT BE STANDING HERE TODAY WITHOUT MY MOTHER. I'M SO THANKFUL SHE PAVED THE WAY FOR ME AND A LOT OF OTHER INCREDIBLE WOMEN, UM, THROUGHOUT KENTUCKY, ANA AND BEYOND, SO I'M SO HONORED. AND IF ANYTHING THAT'S JUST INSPIRES ME TO KEEP UP THE WORK. KEEP PURSUING MY DREAMS AND HONESTLY KEEP INSPIRING THE YOUTH OF TODAY BECAUSE OUR FUTURE LEADERS. SO WE GOTTA KEEP POURING INTO THEM. I THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH, AND THIS IS ONLY THE BEGINNING LAST MORE TO COME. THEY CAN GO.

THANK YOU, MISS. THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN BAKER. MADAM CLERK. ARE THERE ANY ADDRESSES TO

[Addresses to the Council]

COUNSEL? YES, SIR. THERE ARE OK, LET ME REMIND THOSE ADDRESSING COUNCIL TO PLEASE REFRAIN FROM USING ANY PROFANITY OR MAKING DEROGATORY STATEMENTS TO COUNCIL MEMBERS. MADAM CLERK, PLEASE CALL THE FIRST SPEAKER RUSS GREENLY. UM HI. I'M RUSS GREENLEAF. I'M JEWISH. I WAS IN SYNAGOGUE SATURDAY, LISTENING TO A RABBI AND TWO ISRAELI CITIZENS EXPLAIN

[00:40:02]

WHY WE NEEDED IMMEDIATE CEASE FIRE IN GAZA. WE SUPPORT THE CEASEFIRE RESOLUTION. WHEN WE HEAR ISRAELI SPOKESPERSONS DENY THAT ISRAEL IS DELIBERATELY KILLING CIVILIANS IN GAZA. WE KNOW THEY'RE LYING. WE KNOW BECAUSE ISRAEL'S LEADERS ARE SAYING THE OPPOSITE IN ISRAEL.

THE VICE CHAIR OF THE ISRAELI KNESSET SAYS BURN GAZA NOW AND LEAVE ONLY ONE OLD MAN THERE TO TELL WHAT HAPPENED. ANOTHER KNESSET MEMBER, SAID ERASE ALL OF GAZA FROM THE FACE OF THE EARTH. ANOTHER KNESSET MEMBER, SAID THERE ARE NO INNOCENTS IN GAZA, MOW THEM DOWN. AND THAT'S WHY MOST OF THE 30,000 PEOPLE ISRAEL HAS KILLED IN GAZA ARE WOMEN AND CHILDREN. THE ATTITUDE OF ISRAEL'S AWFUL LEADERS HAS FILTOTS WHO DROPPED THE BOMBS. VIDEO SHOW ISRAELI SOLDIERS MARCHING INTO GAZA CHANTING THERE ARE NO INNOCENTS IN GAZA. AND THEY ARE MOWING THEM DOWN. AN ISRAELI SNIPER SHOT AND KILLED TWO CHRISTIAN WOMEN WHO WERE WALKING IN THE COURTYARD OF THEIR CHURCH IN GAZA. THEN HE SHOT SEVEN OTHER CHRISTIANS IN THE CHURCH. THAT'S MURDER. IT'S NOT DEFENDING ISRAEL. THIS CNN ARTICLE ABOUT THE ATTACK, SAYS ISRAELI TANKS THEN TARGETED A CHRISTIAN CONVENT THAT HOUSES 54 DISABLED PEOPLE. POPE FRANCIS IS QUOTED SAYING. THIS IS TERRORISM. THIS WAS NO ACCIDENT. YOU HAVE THIS ARTICLE. BY THE WAY, THIS IS NO ACCIDENT. THIS IS WHAT ISRAEL IS DOING IN GAZA. BECAUSE ISRAEL HAS THE WORST LEADERS IT'S EVER HAD. THEY'RE CORRUPT AND IMMORAL , AND THEY'RE TAKING ISRAEL DOWN THE WRONG PATH, AND THEY'RE DRAGGING US DOWN THAT WRONG PATH IF WE CONTINUE TO SUPPORT WHAT THEY'RE DOING. VOTING NO ON THE CEASEFIRE RESOLUTION MEANS YOU'RE CONTINUING YOUR SUPPORT OF WHAT THEY'RE DOING. VOTING PRESENT MEANS YOU'RE OK WITH WHAT THEY'RE DOING, BECAUSE IT DOESN'T BOTHER YOU ENOUGH TO ASK FOR IT TO STOP. VOTING? YES. VOTING YES, ON THE CEASEFIRE RESOLUTIONS MEANS YOU KNOW, IN YOUR HEART THAT KILLING CHRISTIAN WOMEN IN CHURCH IS NOT THE WAY FOR ISRAEL TO DEFEND ITSELF AND YOU WANT ISRAEL TO STOP AND RETHINK WHAT IT'S DOING. JOE BIDEN CAN MAKE A CEASE FIRE HAPPEN. IF ENOUGH CITY COUNCILS PASS RESOLUTIONS, HE MIGHT DO IT. IF YOU'RE A CHRISTIAN VOTE YES. IF YOU CARE ABOUT ISRAEL AND WANT IT TO DO BETTER VOTE YES. YOU WANT IF YOU WANT TO MAKE A LOT OF JEWS IN LOUISVILLE HAPPY VOTE YES. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR GREENLEAF.

THANK YOU, CHAD CARMEN. GOOD EVENING. I'M CHAD KAMMEN. I'M JEWISH, AND I'M JOINING MANY OTHERS IN MY COMMUNITY AND ACROSS THE CITY AND URGING THE PASSING OF THE CEASE FIRE RESOLUTION. THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE SPREADING FEAR IN OUR CITY. THE INSIDIOUS FEAR THAT THIS RESOLUTION IS DIVISIVE. THE IRRATIONAL FEAR THAT A RESOLUTION JOINING A GLOBAL CALL FOR PEACE WILL SOMEHOW UNDO OR BREAK OUR FAITH BASED ALLIANCES HERE IN TOWN. I KNOW THAT'S NOT TRUE. AND I CANNOT LET FEAR PREVENT ME FROM DOING THE RIGHT THING. FOR MY GRIEF OVER THE MURDER OF ENTIRE FAMILIES IN GAZA IS STRONGER THAN MY FEAR OF BEING DIVISIVE, LIKE A PREVIOUS GENERATION'S GRIEF OVER LYNCHING AND SEGREGATION WAS STRONGER THAN THEIR FEAR OVER BEING DIVISIVE. OVERCOMING THE FEAR OF BEING DIVISIVE, MADE THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT POSSIBLE AND LIKE THEN WE SHOULD OVERCOME OUR FEAR AND TAKE A STEP TOWARD JUSTICE. WE CAN FOLLOW IN THEIR FOOTSTEPS. BUT WE MUST CHOOSE TO A MAJORITY OF THE CIVILIANS WANT A CEASEFIRE. WE ARE FIVE MONTHS INTO UNRELENTING VIOLENCE AGAINST THE PEOPLE OF GAZA BY ISRAEL, AND I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE THAT WE DON'T WANT TO SEE ANOTHER 30,000 ELDERS AND PARENTS AND CHILDREN KILLED LET'S MAKE THAT CLEAR BY VOTING FOR THIS RESOLUTION. IT WILL BRING US TOGETHER AS A CITY AND I KNOW THAT FROM PERSONAL EXPERIENCE SUPPORTING THE CEASEFIRE RESOLUTION HAS BROUGHT ME INTO DEEPER COMMUNITY WITH A LARGE, DIVERSE COALITION OF LOUIS WILLIANS, PARTICULARLY JEWISH AND PALESTINIAN AMERICANS , WHO ARE WORKING TOGETHER TO WITNESS EACH OTHER TO ALLOW OUR GRIEF TO FUEL A UNITY WHERE NO ONE'S PAIN IS SILENCED BECAUSE IT MAKES US UNCOMFORTABLE OR

[00:45:03]

ASHAMED, BUT THIS CITY HAS ALREADY MADE THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE WHO CALL LOUISVILLE DON'T FEEL LESS THAN HUMAN BY LIGHTING UP THE BIG FOUR BRIDGE WITH THE COLORS OF THE ISRAELI FLAG, WELL IN TONING TO THEM THAT NOW IS NOT THE TIME FOR THEIR PAIN THAT IT MAY BE TOO DIVISIVE TO SAY THAT OUR CITY DOES NOT STAND WITH THEM AS THEY'RE WATCHING THEIR FAMILIES AND THEIR CULTURAL INSTITUTIONS AND THEIR LIVES BE DESTROYED. METRO COUNCIL. WE HAVE THE POWER TO CHANGE THAT THERE IS A MOVEMENT ACROSS THIS COUNTRY OF CITIES LIKE OURS PASSING RESOLUTIONS URGING OUR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO MAKE A CEASE FIRE HAPPEN. WE CANNOT ACHIEVE THIS ALONE. BUT WE'RE HERE TODAY BECAUSE WE ARE NOT ALONE. I REMEMBER ONCE AS A KID BEING SO UPSET WHEN I HEARD SOME OF MY CLOSEST MUSLIM FRIENDS WENT TO A RALLY FOR PALESTINE BETWEEN TEARS, I ASKED MY MOM, WHY DO MY FRIENDS HATE US? AND I'M HERE TODAY BECAUSE I KNOW THAT THE ONLY HATE THAT IS EVER SEPARATED US IS THAT WHICH ALLOWED ME TO BELIEVE THAT SOMEONE ADVOCATING FOR THEIR DIGNITY WAS AN ATTACK ON MY OWN. TRUE UNITY IS ONE THAT ALLOWS FOR US TO NOT ONLY WITNESS EACH OTHER'S PAIN BUT TO ACTIVELY ADVOCATE AGAINST THE CONDITIONS WHICH DENY ONE ANOTHER HUMANITY FOR IF WE CAN ACKNOWLEDGE IN ALL OF THIS, THAT OUR PAIN IS TIED TOGETHER, SO TOO, AS A LIBERATION AND THAT DEMANDS WE COME TOGETHER AS A CITY AND VOTE FOR A CEASEFIRE. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, MR KEVIN. THANK YOU, MACY MARTIN. IF I CAN HAVE EVERYONE'S ATTENTION. I'M MACY MARTIN. I'M A CONCERNED CITIZEN, AND I RAISE THE THOUGHTS FOR PALESTINE. THAT OF HOW MANY MORE CHILDREN MUST DIE FOR YOU TO CEASE ON ME. HOW MANY MORE CHILDREN MUST DIE IN A FAMINE MAN MADE INCHES AWAY FROM A TRUCK THAT FEEDS THE HUNGRY MUST THERE PLEADS BE WRAPPED IN GOLD AND IVORY FOR YOU TO CONSIDER ME. THE SCREAMS OF PAIN AS THE BOMBS ARE DROPPED YOUNG CHILDREN AND FAMILIES 30,000, YET SOME STILL HAVE YET TO BE FOUND UNDER THE RUBBLE, WAR CRIMES IN AGONY.

HOW MANY MORE COMPARABLE LIVES MUST PERISH UNDER YOUR RESPONSIBILITY? UNTIL YOU STOP DENYING ME DENYING ME BASICS OF LIFE FOOD, SHELTER SAFETY, DENYING ME HUMANKIND, COMMUNITY DIGNITY AND HUMANITY. HOW MANY MORE CHUNKS OF MY POPULATION MUST HIT THE FLOOR FOR YOU TO STOP IDLING ON ME? AND WHAT ABOUT THE PURPOSEFULLY TARGETED AND BOMBED HOSPITALS AND CAMPS OF INNOCENT CIVILIAN REFUGEES UNTIL YOU SEE ME HOW MANY MORE CITIES DESTROYED UNTIL YOU SEE THE IRONY, WHILE ISRAEL CONTINUES TO BOORISH. THEY'RE NOT STARVING. THEY'RE NOT DYING UNDER RUBBLE. THEY DO NOT CRY AND SCREAM OUT. ALLAH HAVE MERCY ON ME WHILE HOLDING THEIR DEAD MONTHS OLD CHILD. THIS ISN'T WAR ANYMORE. THIS IS A GENOCIDAL ETHNIC CLEANSING. YOU SEE, BECAUSE LOUISVILLE SHOULD NOT BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE $9 MILLION SENT TO THIS ETHNIC CLEANSING MACHINE. WE COULD BE SENDING AID POURING MILLIONS INTO OUR OWN DISPLACED, INCREASING JOBS, FOOD AND HOUSING. ACCESSIBILITY. PLEASE OPEN YOUR EYES. HOW MANY SHREDDED DREAMS AND FAMILIES MUST BE BROADCAST. HOW MANY MORE ACTIVE DUTY MARTYRS SHOULD BE SELF IMMOLATING IN EXTREME PROTEST? HOW MANY MORE PEOPLE CRYING SCREAMING, MUST YOU SEE TO STOP QUESTIONING AND KNOW THIS IS NOT WHERE OUR TAXES SHOULD GO. LOUISVILLE IS OUR HOME AND SHOULD NOT BE A MANUFACTURER OF A MILITARY EQUIPMENT THAT'S PACKAGED UP IN BOWS AND READY TO GO BLOW TO BLOW AN OPEN FIRE ON STARVING PEOPLE SEEKING FLOUR TO FILL THEIR STOMACHS AFTER EATING NOTHING BUT SCRAPS AND BLOWN ASH BLOWN ASHES OF CITY REMAINS FAMILY MEMORIES AND SCREAMS OF PAIN. HOW MANY GUT WRENCHING PAINS OF UNDIGESTIBLE ANIMAL FEED PUCKS MUST BE EATEN RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOUR FACE TODAY FOR YOU. SAY I'M IN FAVOR OF A TRUE CEASE FIRE AND I'LL STAND WITH GAZA UNTIL THEY CAN BECAUSE THAT SPARK IN YOU ABOUT THE GREATER PLAN. IS STILL THERE WHEN A KID ASKS YOU IF YOU COULD HAVE ANYTHING IN THE WORLD, AND YOU SAID WORLD PEACE. TO STOP WORLD HUNGER. TO CEASE WAR AND YOU CAN AND NOW'S YOUR CHANCE. YOU'RE PART OF THIS TIMELINE TO ENACT THE PLANS. BECAUSE A BUTTERFLY WHO FLAPS THEIR WINGS ACROSS THE OCEAN RIPPLES, TSUNAMIS HAVE CHANGED TO TIE LOOSE ENDS OF THE WORLD FREE GAZA. CEASEFIRE FREE PALESTINE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.

LEAN AZAD. GOOD EVENING COUNCIL MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LENA ABU ZAYED. I ADDRESS YOU TODAY AS A

[00:50:02]

HEALTH CARE WORKER. YOU ABOUT ALUMNI, FULL BRIGHT SCHOLAR AND A CHILD OF PALESTINIAN REFUGEES.

FIVE MONTHS AGO. TODAY I NEVER THOUGHT THAT I WOULD BE STANDING HERE BEFORE YOU TO PLEAD THE GROWING CASE OF HEALTH CARE INACCESSIBILITY IN LOUISVILLE AND THE GENOCIDE AGAINST MY PEOPLE FIVE MONTHS AGO TODAY I NEVER THOUGHT THAT I WOULD BE READING OVER THE PALESTINE HEALTH MINISTRY'S DEATH TOLL REPORT TO FIND OVER 40 MEMBERS OF MY FAMILY ON THIS LIST.

HASSAN YUSUF ABLA AHMED, FOUR NAMES THAT ARE ONLY FOUR OF THE 53 AND COUNTING MEMBERS OF MY FAMILY IN GAZA THAT HAVE BEEN KILLED BY THE OCCUPATION REGIME SINCE OCTOBER, 7 KENTUCKY HAS THE THIRD HIGHEST DEATH RATE AGE ADJUSTED PER 100,000 PEOPLE IN THE UNITED STATES. KENTUCKY IS ALSO RANKED 47TH HIGHEST, BASED ON LIFE EXPECTANCY AS OF 2020. COMPARED TO SIX YEARS AGO.

JEFFERSON COUNTY HAS SEEN A DECLINE IN LIFE EXPECTANCY, THE CURRENT LIFE EXPECTANCY FOR RESIDENTS IS ABOUT 74.8 YEARS, HOWEVER, THE LIFE AVERAGE LIFE EXPECTANCY IN THE NORTHWEST CORE WERE PREDOMINANTLY BLACK RESIDENTS LIVE A 65.4 YEARS, 15 YEARS LESS THAN THOSE THOSE LIVING IN THE EASTERN PART OF THE COUNTY. AS A HEALTHCARE WORKER. I OFTEN WORK WITH VETERANS OF IRAQ, VIETNAM AND OTHER REGIONS. THESE ARE PATIENTS THAT SUFFER WITH PTSD ACCELERATED HEALTH DISEASE AND AN ASTONISHING RATE OF HEART DISEASE AND MANY OTHER TREATABLE AFFLICTIONS. I'VE SEEN PATIENTS REMOVED FROM THE EMERGENCY ROOM AND THROWN INTO THE STREETS AND PATIENTS THAT ARE UNABLE TO CONSENT TO RECEIVING CARE DUE TO AN INABILITY TO AFFORD INSURANCE. THE TERMS OF A CRISIS OF HEALTH CARE INEQUITY IN LOUISVILLE IS A SOLVABLE ONE, THOUGH NOT IMMEDIATE. AS WE LOOK BACK THROUGH AMERICAN HISTORY, WE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE MONTGOMERY BUS BOYCOTT DIDN'T END SEGREGATION IMMEDIATELY. NOR DID MUHAMMAD ALI'S DEFIANCE BEING ENLISTED IN THE VIETNAM WAR. BUT BOTH WERE HAILED AS ACTS OF DEFIANCE THAT WENT DOWN IN HISTORY AS THOSE THAT MOVED AGAINST THE NATION'S TIDE. WHEN LOCAL TAXPAYERS REJECT SENDING MILLIONS OF OUR FEDERAL TAX DOLLARS TO AN OCCUPYING COUNTRY IN THE MIDDLE EAST. THIS IS AN ACT THAT ALLOWS US I WOULD ASK YOU TO STAY ON THE TOPIC THAT YOU SIGNED UP TO SPEAK, PLEASE.

THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THIS IS AN ACT THAT ALLOWS US TO BETTER FUND LIFE-GIVING SERVICES LIKE HEALTH CARE ACCESS IN OUR COMMUNITY TO STAND AGAINST BILLS AND POLICIES THAT ENABLE THE FUNDING AND MILITARIZED WEAPONRY AND AID THAT TRANSLATES TO BILLIONS OF THE NATION'S DOLLARS IS AN ACT OF JUSTICE FOR THE CITY. I DO NOT WANT TO INTERRUPT YOU. EXCUSE ME. EXCUSE ME.

EXCUSE ME. WE HAVE RULES RELATED TO SIGNING UP TO SPEAK. I DO NOT WANT TO CUT PEOPLE OFF. I DO NOT WANT TO INTERRUPT PEOPLE AND I DO NOT WANT TO ASK YOU TO LEAVE. WE ARE HAPPY TO LISTEN TO PEOPLE WHO SPEAK BUT WE WILL THERE YOU SIGN UP FOR A REASON. THOSE ARE THE RULES. AND THOSE ARE THE RULES THAT WE WILL FOLLOW. THANK YOU. MR FOR CAN I ADDRESS THE FACT THAT THERE IS SOMEBODY SPEAKING TODAY? THAT DOESN'T LIVE IN KENTUCKY? THAT DOESN'T LIVE IN LOUISVILLE. SORRY, BUT IT'S SPEAKING. I GUESS THE RESOLUTION WE HAVE I SIGNED UP TO SPEAK ON THE HEALTH CARE TOPIC BE.

MADAM DAN. MADAM CLERK, MADAM CLERK. IF WE COULD CALL THE NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE. BE A BUM. WHAT ARE WE DOING? YEAH. MELANIE, POW. IF WE COULD IF WE COULD PLEASE REMOVE PEOPLE. THANK YOU.

WOW. GOOD EVENING. OK, THANK YOU, MADAM CLERK. IF YOU COULD CALL THE NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.

THANK YOU. THE FLOOR IS YOURS. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS MELANIE POWELL. AND I'M A PROUD NATIVE

[00:55:10]

LOUISVILLE WITH DEEP LOVE FOR THIS GREAT CITY. IN MY PROFESSIONAL CAPACITY. I AM THE CHIEF FIELD OPERATIONS OFFICER FOR THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE, A GLOBAL ADVOCACY ORGANIZATION FOR THE JEWISH PEOPLE. EXACTLY ONE YEAR AGO, I WAS IN ISRAEL STANDING ON THE BORDER BETWEEN ISRAEL AND GAZA, AND I WISH SOME OF OUR FRIENDS THAT JUST LEFT WE'RE HERE TO HEAR ME TELL THIS STORY. I WAS MEETING WITH THE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE REGIONAL COUNCIL PEOPLE IN ROLLS VERY SIMILAR TO YOURS, WHO REPRESENT THE KIBBUTZ SEEM THE TOWNS, THE VILLAGES AND COMMUNITIES ALONG THE SOUTHERN BORDER OF ISRAEL, THE MAYOR OF FEAR, LIEB EXCITEDLY DESCRIBED THE INDUSTRIAL ZONE THAT THEY WERE BUILDING SO THAT TENS OF THOUSANDS OF THEIR PALESTINIAN NEIGHBORS FROM GAZA COULD COME WORK EVERY DAY AND EARN A LIVING. HE HAD A VISION. HE BELIEVED HE LONGED FOR PEACE. THIS WAS HIS LIFE'S WORK. AND ON OCTOBER 7TH HE WAS MURDERED. HIS 19 YEAR OLD SON, NAN WAS MURDERED. HIS MOTHER IN LAW WAS MURDERED. HIS NEPHEW WAS MURDERED. THESE PLANNED ATROCITIES TARGETED CIVILIANS WITH MORE THAN 1200, MEN, WOMEN AND CHILDREN AND INFANTS SLAUGHTERED THAT DAY AND MORE THAN 250 TAKEN CAPTIVE INTO GAZA. OUT OF THOSE TAKEN HOSTAGE 132 ARE STILL BEING HELD, INCLUDING 19 WOMEN, 14 OF THEM YOUNG WOMEN. THE IMMEDIATE RELEASE OF THESE HOSTAGES MUST BE A TOP PRIORITY. WE'VE SEEN THE HARROWING UNITED NATIONS REPORT THAT DETAILED THE HORRIFIC SEXUAL TORTURE ENDURED BY THE WOMEN MASSACRED ON OCTOBER 7TH AND EVIDENCE THAT THOSE BEING HELD IN GAZA UNDERWENT AND ARE STILL SUBJECT TO SIMILAR ATROCITIES. THE UN SECRETARY GENERAL ON SEXUAL VIOLENCE AND CONFLICT LED A TEAM TO INVESTIGATE THE SEXUAL VIOLENCE. HER REPORT, WHICH WAS RELEASED MARCH 4TH DETAILS EVIDENCE OF SYSTEMIC WEAPONIZED SEXUAL VIOLENCE, INCLUDING RAPE AND GANG RAPE AND THE RAPE OF CORPSES. MANY FEMALES WERE FOUND NAKED OR PARTIALLY NAKED WITH THEIR GENITAL SHOT AND MUTILATED. THE WOMEN WHO HAVE ALREADY BEEN HELD CAPTIVE FOR FIVE MONTHS ARE LIVING UNDER CONDITIONS. WE HOPE THEY'RE LIVING. WE DON'T KNOW, BUT THEY'RE BEING HELD UNDER CONDITIONS TOO DIFFICULT TO COMPREHEND. THERE IS A CEASE FIRE PROPOSAL ON THE TABLE TODAY AND THAT HAS BEEN ON THE TABLE FOR SIX WEEKS, AND IT CALLS FOR A PHASE WHERE THE ELDERLY, THE WOMEN, AND THE INJURED WILL BE RELEASED. HAMAS HAS REJECTED THAT CEASEFIRE AS THEY HAVE REJECTED EVERY CEASEFIRE PROPOSAL AND VIOLATED THE CEASEFIRE THAT WAS ACTUALLY IN EFFECT ON OCTOBER 6TH. AS NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER JAKE SULLIVAN SAID JUST YESTERDAY. HAMAS'S REJECTION OF THIS PROPOSAL SHOWS WHAT LITTLE REGARD THEY HAVE FOR PALESTINIAN CIVILIANS. ALL OF OUR LIVES CHANGED ON OCTOBER 7TH THE PAIN, THE FEAR THE LOSS. THE GRIEF FELT BY ALL OF US ALL WHO WERE IMPACTED BY THIS WAR, A WAR HAMAS STARTED. HAMAS IS THE ENEMY, NOT THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE. LET'S FREE GAZA FROM HAMAS. IF I BELIEVED FOR ONE MOMENT THAT THIS EFFORT IN THE METRO COUNCIL WOULD LEAD TO BRINGING HOME THE HOSTAGES, I WOULD SUPPORT IT. WE ALL WANT PEACE. WE ALL WANT AN END TO SUFFERING. UH, WE URGE YOU TO CONSIDER HOW YOU CAN BE A FORCE FOR HEALING AND NOT A FORCE FOR CONTINUED DIVISION IN WHAT IS CLEARLY A DIVIDED COUNCIL AND A DIVIDED MOMENT FOR SO MANY OF US. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MISS RABBI SHALOM LITZ. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS A LIEN. I'M AN EMISSARY OF LAREEN, THE FOREMOST JEWISH LEADER OF THE MODERN ERA. I ALSO SERVE AS CHAIRMAN OF THE KENTUCKY JEWISH COUNCIL. AND I AM THE SECOND RABBI IN HISTORY TO BE BORN IN LOUISVILLE AND SERVE IN LOUISVILLE. I RISE TODAY TO ADDRESS THE PERFORMATIVE RESOLUTION. SEEMING TO CALL FOR A CEASE FIRE IN ISRAEL'S WAR AGAINST THE GENOCIDAL HAMAS TERRORIST ORGANIZATION. THAT BEGAN FOLLOWING THE ATROCITIES OF OCTOBER 7TH. THE PRO HAMAS PROTESTERS BEHIND THIS RESOLUTION, IGNORE THE SLAUGHTER AND RAPE OF OCTOBER 7TH. AND THE MORE THAN 100 HOSTAGES, INCLUDING AMERICANS WHO ARE STILL BEING HELD LIKE NINE MONTH OLD QUEER B BOSS. AND IT TA CHEN, A 19 YEAR OLD BOY, WHO WE JUST FOUND OUT TWO DAYS AGO WAS MURDERED IN HAMAS CAPTIVITY. ACCOMPANIED BY FABRICATED ACCUSATIONS AND CALLS FOR FURTHER VIOLENCE AGAINST JEWS, BOTH HERE IN LOUISVILLE AND IN THEIR HOMELAND. THESE DEMANDS IGNORE TWO CRUCIAL FACTS. THE FIRST IS AND I HOPE I DON'T HURT ANYBODY'S FEELINGS HERE. THE LOUISVILLE CITY COUNCIL DOESN'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO END THE WAR IN GAZA. UH, BENJAMIN NETANYAHU IS NOT WAITING TO HEAR WHAT LOUISVILLE HAS TO SAY BEFORE HE PLANS THE NEXT OPERATION.

NEITHER IS HAMAS. SECONDLY, AND THERE ARE ISSUES THAT THE COUNCIL CAN DEAL WITH HERE AT HOME, STANDING HERE THE DAY AFTER THE FOURTH ANNIVERSARY OF MARCH, 13TH I DON'T HAVE TO GO ON FURTHER THAN THAT. SECONDLY CALLS FOR A CEASEFIRE SUPERFLUOUS BECAUSE THERE'S ALREADY A CEASE FIRE OFFER ON THE TABLE. ISRAEL HAS MADE TWO VERY SIMPLE AND MORAL REQUESTS

[01:00:04]

TO RETURN TO THE HOSTAGES WHO WERE KIDNAPPED ON OCTOBER 7TH, INCLUDING THE DEAD BODY STILL BEING HELD AND THE DISARMAMENT OF THE MASS TERRORIST ORGANIZATION, SO THEY CANNOT, AS THEY SWORE TO CARRY OUT FURTHER ATTACKS LIKE OCTOBER 7TH. WAS A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF ANTI SEMITIC LIES THAT WERE EXPELLED HERE TODAY. SOME OF THEM STRAIGHT. THE PROTOCOLS, THE OTHERS THE ZION AND I WON'T ADDRESS ALL OF THEM. BUT I WILL SAY THAT THE FALSE ACCUSATION OF GENOCIDE IS NOTHING MORE THAN AN ANTI SEMITIC BLOOD LEVEL. AND THE IDEA THAT LOUISVILLE MONEY IS GOING TO ISRAEL IS SIMPLY MISINFORMED AT BEST. A CEASEFIRE RESOLUTION WOULD NOT AFFECT GAZA. BUT IT WOULD AFFECT OUR COMMUNITY HERE IN LOUISVILLE. IT WOULD NOT AFFECT ANYTHING IN ISRAEL'S POLICY. IT WOULD NOT AFFECT ANYTHING IN THE POLICY OF HAMAS, WHICH ITS RESOLUTION DOESN'T HAVE EITHER THE MORALITY OR THE COURAGE TO NAME THE ONLY PEOPLE THAT WILL HEAR THIS CEASEFIRE IS THE JEWISH COMMUNITY OF LOUISVILLE, THE LARGEST JEWISH COMMUNITY IN THE STATE, IN WHICH EVERY MAJOR ORGANIZATION HAS SPOKEN OUT AGAINST THE CEASEFIRE AND THE PROTESTERS WHO ON OCTOBER 8TH WERE CELEBRATING WHAT HAD HAPPENED. ON NOVEMBER, 18TH MARCHED ON A SYNAGOGUE HERE IN LOUISVILLE. AND WHO GATHERED OUTSIDE HERE TO YELL VICTORY FOR GAZA, THE GENOCIDAL CALL FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA AND NOT CALLS FOR CEASEFIRE BUT FOR A BLOODY VICTORY FOR HAMAS. HAS SEEN. THEY DON'T EVEN WANT TO HEAR JEWISH VOICES BUT WOULD RATHER STORM OUT THAN HAVE CONVERSATION. I PRAY FOR PEACE IN THE HOLY LAND, AND I BELIEVE THAT EVERYONE HERE IN THIS COUNCIL JOINS ME. PEACE WILL COME THE MOMENT THAT HAMAS CHOOSES A BETTER FUTURE FOR THEIR CHILDREN OVER THE ABILITY TO KILL OURS. GOD BLESSED THE HEROES OF THE ID F AS THEY PROTECT EVERY CITIZEN OF ISRAEL, JEWISH, MUSLIM OR OTHERWISE.

BRING THE HOSTAGES HOME. BRING THEM HOME NOW. I'M YES, AL K. THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL LIVE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, RABBI. WATCH THIS.

HELLO. MY NAME IS GARY WATRES. I LIVE IN DISTRICT FIVE. I'M AN ARCHITECT SPECIALIZING IN ENERGY EFFICIENT DESIGN. AND I'M, A MEMBER OF THE RENEWABLE ENERGY ALLIANCE OF LOUISVILLE. I WANT TO THANK YOU ALL FOR PASSING METRO RESOLUTION 102. THAT RESOLUTION HAD VARIOUS GOALS.

THE FIRST GOAL WAS TO HAVE ALL METRO GOVERNMENT BUILDINGS USE ONLY CLEAN, RENEWABLE ENERGY BY THE YEAR 2030. NOW THAT'S JUST SIX YEARS FROM NOW. THE GOAL IS AMBITIOUS. BUT IT CAN BE DONE.

LET'S PUT OUR MONEY WHERE OUR RESOLUTION IS PLEASE BUDGET MONEY TO MAKE THIS RESOLUTION A REALITY. YOUR ENERGY MANAGER ZACHARY TAYLOR IS WORKING ON ENERGY UPGRADES FOR METRO BUILDINGS, BUT ENERGY UPGRADES WILL ONLY GO SO FAR. TO GO THE WHOLE WAY TOWARD CLEAN RENEWABLE ELECTRICITY BY 2030 FOR METRO BUILDINGS, YOU MUST START THE BUDGET MONEY FOR SOLELY SOLAR ELECTRIC NOW. PROVIDING ALL METRO BUILDINGS WITH SOLAR ELECTRICITY WOULD SAVE $12 MILLION A YEAR. FOR THE NEXT 30 TO 50 YEARS. YOU ASK, HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE? WELL THE PANELS PAY FOR THEMSELVES IN THE 1ST 10 YEARS. AFTER WHICH METRO WOULD GET FREE ELECTRICITY FOR THE NEXT 20 TO 40 YEARS. THE MONEY SAVED. COULD BE USED FOR SO MANY PROJECTS TO BENEFIT YOUR CONSTITUENTS. AS A GOOD FIRST STEP, PLEASE BUDGET $1 MILLION. FOR SOLAR ELECTRIC FOR SEVERAL METRO BUILDINGS IN THIS UPCOMING BUDGET. THIS COULD BE REGARDED AS SEED MONEY. UH, FOR CONVINCING THE EPA THAT WE ARE SERIOUS ABOUT SOLAR AND DESERVE MORE FEDERAL FUNDING FOR SOLAR, ELECTRIC AND METRO BUILDINGS. TIME IS SHORT. PLEASE TAKE ACTION TO UPHOLD YOUR RESOLUTION. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION, KEITH MORGAN. KEITH MORGAN. MR PRESIDENT THAT CONCLUDES THE ADDRESS AS A COUNCIL. THANK YOU, MADAM CLERK. NEXT WE HAVE APPROVAL OF THE

[6. ID 24-0119     Regular:  Metro Council – February 29, 2024]

COUNCIL MINUTES FOR THE REGULAR MEETING OF FEBRUARY. 29TH 2024. ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS OR DELETIONS HEARING? NONE MAY HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND FOR APPROVAL. THE MOTION BY COUNCILMAN BEAN, SECOND BY COUNCILMAN SIMON THAT HE'S PROPERLY BEEN MO MINUTES HAVE BEEN PROPERLY MOVED AND SECONDED . ALL THOSE IN FAVOR. SAY AYE, I AND HE OPPOSED THE AYES HAVE IT THESE MINUTES HAVE BEEN APPROVED AS WRITTEN. NEXT WE HAVE APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING COMMITTEE MINUTES, ALL IN 2024 REGULAR COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE FEBRUARY 29TH REGULAR PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE, MARCH 5TH REGULAR LABOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND APPROPRIATIONS

[Committee Minutes]

COMMITTEE. MARCH 5TH REGULAR PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE, MARCH 5TH REGULAR GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT , AUDIT AND APPOINTMENTS COMMITTEE. MARCH 5TH REGULAR EQUITY COMMUNITY AFFAIRS,

[01:05:04]

HOUSING, HEALTH AND EDUCATION COMMITTEE. MARCH 6TH REGULAR PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE, MARCH 6TH SPECIAL AD HOC LAND USE COMMITTEE, UH, MARCH 7TH REGULAR PARKS AND SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE MARCH 7TH REGULAR BUDGET. MARCH 7TH. ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS OR DELETIONS HEARING ? NONE MAY HAVE A SECOND, A MOTION AND A SECOND FOR APPROVAL MOTION BY COUNCILMAN SIMONS SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN ENGLE. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE AYE. ANY OPPOSED THE EYES HAVE IT

[Consent Calendar]

THESE MINUTES HAVE BEEN APPROVED AS WRITTEN. OUR NEXT ORDER OF BUSINESS IS THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE CONSENT CALENDAR COMPRISES ITEMS 17 THROUGH 28 WITH THE REMOVAL OF ITEM 21. UM ARE THERE ANY OTHER ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS? HEARING NONE. MADAM CLERK A SECOND READING OF THESE ITEMS, PLEASE. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS PORTED FROM THE BUDGET COMMITTEE ITEM. 17 IN ORDINANCE. AMMIT ORDINANCE NUMBER 079 SERIES 2023 RELATING TO THE FISCAL YEAR 2023 2024 OPERATING BUDGET BY TRANSFERRING $40,000 FROM THE NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUND. DISTRICTS WITH SIX TO THE LOWER METRO. COUNSEL GENERAL OPERATIONS DISTRICTS, 26 . THE PRIMARY LEGISLATION WAS FORWARDED FROM GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT, AUDIT AND APPOINTMENTS COMMITTEE ITEM 18, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING COUNCIL MEMBER TAMMY HAWKINS AS METRO COUNCIL'S REPRESENTATIVE TO THE WEST END OPPORTUNITY PARTNERSHIP BOARD OUT OF 19, AN APPOINTMENT OF REBECCA REED TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THAT EXPIRES FEBRUARY. 9 2026 ITEM 20 AN APPOINTMENT OF PAMELA WAT TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DO BOARD TERM EXPIRES FOR THE 9 2025 ITEM. 22 THE APPOINTMENT AT BEN CECIL TO THE TREE ADVISORY COMMITTEE TERM. NO TERM EXPOSURE FROM THE 29 2025. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS REPORTED FROM LABOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. I'M 23 , THE OWNER, APPROPRIATING $25,500 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER. $1875 FROM DISTRICT 15 $1500 EASTERN DISTRICT 2346789, 1012, 1417, 19 AND 26 $750 EACH FROM DISTRICT 2022, 2324 AND $375 EACH FROM DISTRICT 1321 AND 2530 OFFICE AND MANAGEMENT BUDGET TO KENTUCKY SHAKESPEARE INC FOR THE COST OF PRODUCTION FOR THE SEVENTH ANNUAL SHAKESPEARE IN THE PARKS TOUR IN PARKS IN JEFFERSON COUNTY ITEM. 24 RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION NUMBER 08102 23 REGARDING THE GRANTING OF LOCAL INCENTIVES TO L, A DIAGNOSTICS LLC AND ANY SUBSEQUENT ASSIGNEE. OR APPROVED AFFILIATES THERE PURSUANT TO KRS CHAPTER 154 SUB CHAPTER 32 TO THE LATEST IN REGARDING THE STATE LOCAL PARTICIPATION RATE RATIO. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS FORWARDED FROM THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE, ADDING 25 RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE PLANNING COMMISSION REVIEW THE METRO OF LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REGULATIONS AND REGARD TO NOTICE REQUIREMENTS FOR REVISED DEVELOPMENT PLANS. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS FORWARDED FROM PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ITEM 26 A RESOLUTION TO THE CAPITOL OPERATING BUDGET ORDINANCES APPROVING APPROPRIATION UPON THE FOLLOWING NON COMPATIBLE NEGOTIATED SOURCE CONTRACT FOR FIRE CONTAINING STRUCTURAL COLLAPSE. RESCUE TRAINING SPEC RESCUE INTERNATIONAL $78,000 ITEM 27 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT $30,000 OF FUNDING FROM THE MOTOR CARRIER SAFETY ASSISTANCE PROGRAM. M CS A P THROUGH THE INTERSTATE EMPHASIS GRANT PROGRAM, TO BE ADMINISTERED BY LOCAL METRO POLICE DEPARTMENT OF FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS FORWARDED FROM PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE ITEM 28 RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT UP TO 880,000 DOLLARS OF FUNDING FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY'S TRANSPORTATION CABINET TOWARDS THE OLD BARSTOW ROAD REALIGNMENT PROJECT AND TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND ASSETS, RIGHT. UH, COULD I GET A MOTION AND SECOND FOR APPROVAL? A MOTION BY COUNCILOR BAKER SECONDED BY COUNCILOR MP ARGENTINA, UH, THE CONSENT CALENDAR HAS BEEN PROPERLY MOVED AND SECONDED. IT REQUIRES A ROLL CALL. VOTE, MADAM CLERK, PLEASE.

IF IN THE VOTING COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES. COUNCIL MEMBER MCCRANEY.

DO YOU SEE MY. MR. PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 25? YES. VOTES THANK YOU. THE CONSENT CALENDAR PASSES . UH, THE NEXT ITEM OF BUSINESS IS OLD BUSINESS. UH, ITEM 29 IS BEING HELD AT THE REQUEST OF THE

[29. R-007-24     A RESOLUTION URGING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS AND PRESIDENT TO FACILITATE A CEASEFIRE IN PALESTINE AND ISRAEL (AMENDMENT BY SUBSTITUTION). 3/6/24   Equity, Community Affairs, Housing, Health and Education Committee  Recommended for Approval  2/21/24  Equity, Community Affairs, Housing, Health and Education Committee  Held 2/7/24   Equity, Community Affairs, Housing, Health and Education Committee  Held Action Required By:  August 2024 Sponsors: Jecorey Arthur (I-4), Shameka Parrish-Wright (D-3)]

SPONSOR. UM MAN CLERK. A READING OF ITEM 21 APPOINTMENT OF GARY DRYDEN TO THE MALL. DOWNTOWN

[21. AP030524GD     APPOINTMENT OF GARY DRYDEN TO THE LOUISVILLE DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT DISTRICT BOARD. (TERM EXPIRES FEBRUARY 16, 2026) 3/5/24 Government Oversight/Audit & Appointments Committee Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: ]

MANAGEMENT DISTRICT BOARD TERM EXPIRES FEBRUARY 16TH 2026 RED INFO. MOTION BY COUNCILOR SECOND BY COUNCILMAN SO, UH, THIS COLLEAGUE OR, UH, IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION? UH, THIS IS FROM, UH, APPOINTMENTS. COUNCILMAN ACKERSON SO I APOLOGIZE. OH, CHORY WANTS TO ABSTAIN. UH, I WOULD I WAS ABSENT FROM THIS SO I WOULD TURN TO MY COLLEAGUE MY CO-CHAIR COUNCILMAN HUDSON TO, UH, TO SPEAK TO THIS. YEAH, THIS CAME OFF OF CONCERN BECAUSE I'VE BEEN, UH, AN ABSTENTION. THAT YOU, UH, COUNCILMAN, UM ARTHUR. THANK YOU OUT OF ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION FOR PERCEIVED CONFLICT.

[01:10:04]

I'M ON THE BOARD OF THE DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT DISTRICT. SO I'M ABSTAINING FOR THIS VOTE. YOU EVEN AS IT IS AN ITEM THAT NORMALLY WOULD ALLOW FOR A VOICE VOTE. UH, WE NEED TO DO A ROLL CALL VOTE TO ALLOW FOR THE ABSTENTION. MADAM CLERK, PLEASE. IF FROM THE VOTING COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES.

MR PRESIDENT. YOU HAVE 23? YES. ONE MOMENT. LET ME JUST MAKE SURE UM, I'M SORRY. 23 YES VOTE AND ONE ABSTENTION LIKE YOU. THE ITEM PASSES MADAM CLERK, A READING OF ITEM 30. AND ON A

[30. O-047-24     AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE ZONING OF PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 9201, 9203, 9300, 9307, 9308, 9400, & 9402 CANE RUN ROAD CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY 19.97 ACRES AND BEING IN LOUISVILLE METRO (CASE NO. 23ZONE0139) (AS AMENDED). 3/5/24  Planning and Zoning Committee  Amended;  Recommended for Approval Action Required By:  May 1, 2024 Sponsors: Madonna Flood (D-24) ]

RELATED TO THE ZONING IN A PROPERTY LOCATED AT 92 01 92 03 9393, 07, 93, 08 9400 AND 94 2 CAN RUN ROAD CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY 19.97 ACRES AND BEING A METRO OK, NUMBER 23 ZONE 0139 AS A READ IN FULL MOTION MOTION BY COUNCILOR PINI SECOND BY COUNCILMAN ARTHUR, IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION COUNCILMAN? FLOOD THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. THIS SIDE IS THE MIKE LENNINGS PROPERTY. THE SITE CONSISTS OF 20 ACRES MIKE LENNINGS HAS HAS BEEN AT HIS CURRENT LOCATION FOR 98 YEARS. THERE WERE NO ZONING LAWS BACK WHEN THEY FIRST OPENED UP FOR BUSINESS. THEREFORE THEY HAVE HAD NON CONFORMING RIGHTS ALL THIS TIME. WITH THE LAND USE CHANGE. THERE WILL NO LONGER BE A NEED FOR THESE RIGHTS. THE ZONING WILL ACCOMMODATE A NEW DINING PAVILION EVENT SPACE AND EXPANDED PARKING. THE MAIN AREA OF DISCUSSION AND CONCERN CENTERED AROUND THE PEDESTRIAN SAFETY WHEN CROSSING CAN RUN ROAD FROM THE LARGE PARKING AREA TO THE RESTAURANT. IN COMMITTEE.

UM, WE WERE TOLD THAT THERE ARE THREE NOTES MADE BY KENTUCKY. UH, KYTC ON THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN CONCERNING THE CROSSWALK NUMBER ONE THERMOPLASTIC CROSSING AND YIELD BAR MARKINGS NUMBER TWO PEDESTRIAN WARNING SIGNS ALONG THE RECTANGULAR, RAPID FLASHING BEACON AREA NUMBER THREE DOUBLE LINE STRIPING TO ELIMINATE PASSING WITHIN 500 FT. OF THE CROSSWALK DUE TO THESE BEING, UM CONCERNS BY KYTC. THEY WOULD MAKE THE DETERMINATION OF WHEN WILL BE ENFORCED. WE ADDED BINDING ELEMENT NUMBER 11 AT A SUGGESTION FROM COUNCILWOMAN FOWLER ADDING THE IN IT STATES IF PERMITTED BY KYTC RUMBLE STRIPS SHALL BE INSTALLED BEFORE THE CROSSWALK, AND WE ALSO ADDED BINDING ELEMENT NUMBER 12, WHICH WAS THE STANDARD BINDING ELEMENT THAT WE ADDED AS IF THERE WAS A CHANGE IN USE OR DENSITY, BUT, UH, WITH THEM BEING THERE FOR 98 YEARS, WE DON'T KNOW THAT THAT WOULD BE A, UH, A CONCERN. BUT JUST IN CASE, UM AND I DID HEAR, UM I DID GET IN A TEXT FROM COUNCILWOMAN CINDY FOWLER, WHO'S VERY SUPPORTIVE OF THE REZONING, ESPECIALLY WITH THE, UH, INFORMATION FROM KYTC. THAT'S ALREADY THAT'S ALREADY ON THE PLANS. AND SO WE WOULD ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION? HEARING NONE. THIS IS AN ITEM REQUIRING OF A ROLL CALL VOTE. MADAM CLERK. PLEASE OPEN THE VOTING. COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES. MR. PRESIDENT YOU HAVE 24? YES VOTES. THANK YOU. THE ORDINANCE IS ADOPTED. MADAM CLERK, A READING OF ITEM 31. IN ORDER TO AMEND THE LOUIS JEFFERSON COUNTY METRO

[31. O-022-24     ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LOUISVILLE/JEFFERSON COUNTY METRO GOVERNMENT CODE OF ORDINANCES (“LMCO”) CHAPTER 113 REGULATING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL (AS AMENDED). 3/6/24 Public Safety Committee Amended 3/6/24 Public Safety Committee Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: Rick Blackwell (D-12), Ben Reno-Weber (D-8), Phillip T. Baker (D-6)]

GOVERNMENT CODE OF ORDINANCES. L MC O CHAPTER 113 REGULATING ALCOHOL LIKE BEVERAGE CONTROL AS AMEND, READ IN FULL A MOTION IN A SECOND, UM, MOTION BY COUNCILOR MANINA WEBER. SECOND BY CAN I GET A SECOND? UH, SECOND. THANK YOU. SORRY THANK YOU. SECONDED BY COUNCILOR PACE, RIGHT. SORRY I DIDN'T HEAR IT. UH, IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION, COUNCILMAN HAWKINS? THIS ONE. OK ALL RIGHT, COUNCILMAN, UH, COUNCILMAN SIMON, COULD YOU SPEAK TO THE SAME? IS THIS? THE ONE NO. THE ABC. IT'S A CHANGE. DO YOU WANNA YOU. YOU WANT TO PASS IT TO THE SPONSOR? THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. I WANNA, UH, ASK THE SPONSOR TO SPEAK ON THE POLICE COUNCIL. BLACKWELL THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. SO UM, JUST A COUPLE OF THINGS WITH THIS THIS IS, UM WE? THE REQUEST HERE WAS, UM TO CHANGE, UH, TO USE OUR LOCAL ORDINANCE TO CHANGE. UH, THE PROCESS FOR WHEN THERE IS AN EMERGENCY, UH, IN ONE OF OUR BUSINESSES THAT IS REGULATED BY ABC. UM PRIOR. WELL RIGHT NOW

[01:15:03]

THE LAW IS IF WE DON'T CHANGE IT TONIGHT IS THAT WE HAVE TO REQUEST. IF WE HAVE AN EMERGENCY HERE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY, WE HAVE TO REQUEST FROM THE STATE ABC THAT THEY SHUT IT DOWN. AND AS WE SAW WITH A RECENT REQUEST THAT TAKES SEVERAL DAYS, UH, FORTUNATELY FOR US THE SHOOTING THAT OCCURRED, UM, A FEW WEEKS AGO, UH, OCCURRED ON A SATURDAY NIGHT GOING INTO SUNDAY. SO THE DAYS WHERE THEY WERE DOING THE HEARING WAS A SUNDAY, UH, MONDAY TUESDAY BEFORE WE GOT THE RESULTS THAT COULD HAVE BEEN VERY, VERY DIFFERENT IF THE SHOOTING HAD OCCURRED BETWEEN THURSDAY NIGHT AND FRIDAY MORNING, AND THEN WHILE WE WERE WAITING OF THE STATE ABC WOULD DEEM THIS AN EMERGENCY. THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN OPEN ON SATURDAY AND SUNDAY. I MEAN FRIDAY AND SATURDAY NIGHTS, UH, MIGHT HAVE BEEN A VERY DIFFERENT SITUATION. SO THIS IS, UM, CALLING FOR UH UH, A LOCAL CONTROL, SO OUR LOCAL ABC CAN MAKE THAT DECISION . THERE WAS SOME CONCERN FROM THE, UH, THE OWNERS OF THE BUSINESSES THAT, UM THEY WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAD SOME DEFINITIONS IN PLACE OF WHAT AN EMERGENCY WAS. AND SO THE AMENDMENT THAT MADE IN THE COMMITTEE WAS TO ADOPT THE EXACT SAME LANGUAGE THAT THE STATE USES FOR, UM THE EMERGENCY, SO IT SPELLS OUT THE FIVE THINGS THAT ARE EMERGENCIES. UM SO, UH, I'D APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT AND JUST ONE OTHER COMMENT. SO UM, IS THAT THIS CAME UP. YOU KNOW WHAT? HOW DID I GET INVOLVED IN THIS? BECAUSE THE ISSUES AREN'T HAPPENING IN MY DISTRICT, AND I DID BECAUSE OUR ABC UM ADMINISTRATOR, UH, WAS AT ONE OF MY, UM, DISTRICT DIALOGUES AND WE WERE TALKING AFTERWARDS ABOUT ARE ARE THE THINGS THAT WE CAN DO AS WE OFTEN DO AS ALL OF US. DO YOU KNOW, WE TALK TO OUR AGENCIES ABOUT ALL THE THINGS THAT WE CAN DO ON A COUNCIL LEVEL THAT WOULD MAKE YOUR JOB EASIER. AND UH SO THIS CAME OUT OF THAT CONVERSATION, AND WE'VE BEEN PURSUING IT NOW FOR ACTUALLY FOR SEVERAL MONTHS. THE TIMING OF IT UM, JUST IT IS WHAT IT IS, BUT WE WERE PURSUING IT FOR SEVERAL MONTHS BEFORE SO APPRECIATE A YES VOTE TONIGHT. THANK YOU. COUNCILOR BLACKWELL.

COUNCILMAN PARKER. YES I'M IN THE QUEUE TO EXPLAIN, UH, MY ABSTENTION OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION SINCE I AM, UH, THE OWNER OF A DOG VENUE THAT HAS A LIQUOR LICENSE, AND SO I DON'T THINK THIS WILL. REALLY, UM DIRECTLY AFFECT ME. BUT JUST OUT OF ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, I WILL BE ABSTAINING FROM THE VOTE. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR BERAN. THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. UM I ALMOST ECHO EVERYTHING THAT MARILYNN SAID. EXCEPT FOR I DON'T HAVE A DOG BAR. I HAVE A COULD BE A FEW DOGS IN THERE, BUT NO, UM I OWN A RESTAURANT AND I LIQUOR LICENSE AS WELL.

THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN PERVIS. MR PRESIDENT. I'D LIKE TO BE AIDED AS A SPONSOR, PLEASE. SO NOTED, UH, COUNCILOR MARINO WEBER. I JUST WANT TO, UH, THANK COUNCILOR BLACKWELL FOR DOING SO MUCH GROUND WORK ON THIS, AND I ALSO REALLY WANT TO COMMEND HIM FOR HAVING DONE THE THING THAT I THINK IS MOST IMPORTANT WE ALWAYS DO AND WE ARE CRAFTING LEGISLATION, WHICH IS DIRECTLY ENGAGED WITH THE PEOPLE MOST IMPACTED. UH AND I KNOW THAT YOUR WORK WITH THE RESTAURANT OR THE HOSPITALITY ASSOCIATION, UM AND YOU KNOW, HAVING TALKED TO A LOT OF RESTAURANT OWNERS. UH, THE INCIDENT THAT LOOKS LIKE IT PRECIPITATED THIS, THOUGH IT DID NOT, UH, WAS THE SHOOTING IN OUR DISTRICT. UM AND I. I REALLY APPRECIATE ALL OF THE WORK THAT, UH, THAT THE INSTITUTION IN WHICH THERE WAS A SHOOTING IMMEDIATELY SAID ALL RIGHT, YOU KNOW, THIS IS WE ARE OUR UNINTENTIONALLY THE LOCUS OF A PLACE WHERE BAD, UH, BECOME A PLACE WHERE WHERE BAD ACTORS ARE CONGREGATING, AND WE'RE GONNA BE PROACTIVELY GOOD CITIZENS. SO IN ANTICIPATION OF THIS, THEY, UM HAVE SAID THAT THEY'RE GONNA HIRE SECURITY ON FRIDAY, SATURDAY AND SUNDAY NIGHTS FROM 11 P.M. TO 5 A.M. THEY'RE REALLY AND THEY HAVE VOLUNTARILY SURRENDERED THEIR LIQUOR LICENSE FROM 2 TO 4, SO THAT THERE IS NOT EVEN ANY ACCUSATION THAT THEY WILL CONTINUE TO SERVE PEOPLE WHO SHOULD NOT BE CONTINUED TO BE SERVED. SO I JUST REALLY APPRECIATE ALL THE GROUNDWORK INTO THIS. I APPRECIATE THE PIECES OF THIS THAT ARE NOT LEGISLATIVE. AND I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU. THANK YOU. COUNCILOR MARINO WEBER, COUNCILWOMAN HAWKINS. I WOULD BE ABSTAINING FROM THIS VOTE. UH, I AM A EVENTS. SPACE OWNER. UM SO YEAH. NO I'M DOING BOTH OF THEM.

UM JUST OUT OF EXTREME, UM, OF ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION. SO BECAUSE THEY ARE ABLE TO BRING LIQUOR IN , SO I JUST WANNA BE CAUTIOUS WITH IT AND TRANSPARENT SO I WILL BE STAYING. COUNCILMAN PERISH RIGHT? UH, WE TALKED ABOUT THIS A LOT IN COMMITTEE. I JUST WANT TO REITERATE, UM, FOR THOSE OF US WHO HAVE WHO HAVE DISTRICTS WITH A LOT OF SMALL BUSINESSES, DISTRICTS THAT HAVE GROWING COMMUNITIES THAT HOST PARTIES AND THINGS. WE WENT OVER SOME OF THE DETAILS. THE REASON WHY I AM, UM, GREAT WITH COSPONSOR I. I WOULD I WOULD LIKE TO COSPONSOR AND ALSO THE

[01:20:04]

REASON WHY I SECOND IT IS BECAUSE DURING THE PRESENTATION THAT WE TALKED THOROUGHLY ABOUT EQUITY, THE EQUITY LENS AND COUNCILWOMAN HAWKINS ACTUALLY HAS HER SPACE. IS IN MY DISTRICT , AND I WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS, ESPECIALLY BLACK AND MINORITY, WOULD BE GIVEN THE SAME TREATMENT AS IF THERE WAS ANYWHERE SOMEWHERE NOWHERE BAR IN ANOTHER PART OF TOWN AND ALSO MAKING SURE IT'S ECHOING YOU, UM COUNCILMAN BENRIMO WEBB BECAUSE I'M IMAGINING YOU PROBABLY GOT MORE BARS THAN ANY OF US. IT COMBINED, SO, UH, AND OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE TO HAVE CELEBRATIONS SO JUST MAKING SURE AND THEN I ALSO ASKED THE, UM HIM WHEN HE WAS GIVEN HIS PRESENTATION ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT WE'RE BEING FAIR AND EQUITABLE, GIVING PEOPLE A CHANCE TO WRITE SOME WRONGS AND THEN ALSO THE ADDED PIECE I. I IT DOESN'T THIS LEGISLATION DOESN'T INCLUDE IT, BUT THERE IS A BIG ISSUE WITH WHEN CELEBRITIES UM COME IN, AND THEY'RE ENTOURAGE IS NOT CHECKED OR THEM. THEY'RE NOT CHECKED THE SAME WAY OTHER PATRONS ARE SO THAT CREATES A RISK WHEN THEY'RE ABLE TO BRING IN WEAPONS. SO MAKING SURE THAT WHATEVER WE DO THAT FOLKS ARE THOROUGH, AND I THINK THAT THIS IS A WAY TO HAVE CLEAR LANGUAGE. I APPRECIATE THE SPONSORS, AND I APPRECIATE THE INTENT AROUND THIS, AND I DID ASK THAT. WE CHECK ON THIS TO SEE HOW IT'S GOING. WHO'S LOSING THEIR LICENSE? HOW MANY TIMES WE'VE HAD TO DO AND HOW MANY WARNINGS THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND COLLEAGUES. I JUST WANT TO STATE FOR THE RECORD, I THINK, UM, WHEN THIS ISSUE WAS IN COMMITTEE RIGHT, THERE PROBABLY IS NOT A DIRECT CONFLICT BUT JUST OUT OF AN ABUNDANCE. CAUTION COUNCILWOMAN HARKINS IS ABSTAINING EVEN THOUGH INADVERTENTLY VOTE ON IT. AND, YEAH, DEFINITELY IN, UM, IN COMMITTEE. I DID, I WOULD ASK FOR GRACE, UM AT THAT PARTICULAR TIME, AND I SPOKE ON IT. SO I WOULD JUST ASK FOR A LITTLE GRACE. UM I DIDN'T THINK THAT FOR, UH, EXTREME CAUTION. I DON'T WANT THIS TO TRICKLE DOWN LATER. UM AND AFFECT ME, SO I'M JUST ASKING FOR GRACE RIGHT NOW, UM I DID SPEAK ON IT. SO THANK YOU, COUNCILOR. UH, COUNCILOR OWEN. UM THANK YOU. I JUST WANTED TO SAY HOW MUCH I APPRECIATE, UH, BRAD SILVERIA AND THE WORK THAT HE'S DOING, UM , WE LAST YEAR, COUNCILMAN RENO, WEBER AND I WORKED WITH HIM ON SOME THINGS RELATED TO THE BARS ALONG FRANKFORT AVENUE AND BARSTOW ROAD. AND HE'S BEEN GREAT TO WORK WITH AND I. I THINK WE'RE MAKING SOME INCREMENTAL PROGRESS, WHICH IS FANTASTIC. UH ANY VIOLENCE THAT HAPPENS AT LATE NIGHT ESTABLISHMENTS? YOU KNOW, ONE TIME IS ONE TOO MANY, BUT I DO THINK WE'RE MAKING MAKING PROGRESS. AND, UH, I JUST WANTED TO CALL OUT BREAD BECAUSE I THINK HE'S DOING GREAT WORK. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR OWEN, UH, COUNCILMAN FLOOD.

THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. I WOULD LIKE TO ASK THE PRIMARY SPONSOR IF I COULD BE ADDED AS A, UH COSPONSOR SO NOTED, COUNCILMAN ARTHUR THANK YOU. THERE WAS CONVERSATION IN COMMITTEE ABOUT REPORTING AND MAYBE THIS IS A QUESTION FOR THE COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE. IF THAT WOULD BE NECESSARY, OR WE CAN JUST TAKE THE WORD OF ABC. I'M NOT SURE IF THERE'S ALREADY REPORTING REQUIREMENTS IN THIS CHAPTER. COUNCILOR YOU SAY, REPORTING REPORTING WHAT OF COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT? PROVISIONS WITHIN THE, UM ABC STATUTE. AND OUR LOCAL CODE ENFORCEMENT, BUT THERE ARE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS OF THAT COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT. OH, I, I WOULD HAVE TO LOOK AT THAT EXACTLY. I DIDN'T KNOW I WORK ON THIS LEGISLATION MYSELF. I'M HERE COVERING FOR A COUNTY ATTORNEY. I AM CERTAIN THERE ARE UH, COMPLIANCE MONITORS AND CHECKS. YEAH, I SO I CAN SPEAK TO IT. SO THERE IS A ABC REPORT THAT GIVES BY INDIVIDUAL INSTITUTION ALL OF THE NOT JUST COUNCILMAN, DO YOU MIND SPEAKING INTO YOUR MICROPHONE? THERE IS, IN FACT, AN ABC REPORT. UH THAT HAS EVERY INSTITUTION THAT IS BOTH INVESTIGATED AND THEN CITED BY ABC. UH, THAT YOU COULD. YOU COULD PULL ON REQUEST AND WE CAN ACTUALLY I THINK I'VE GOT IT NOW COMING TO BE QUARTERLY, AND I'M HAPPY TO SHARE. THANK YOU. AND I JUST WANNA CLARIFY THAT'S REPORTING OF WHAT WE'RE CURRENTLY TALKING ABOUT. RIGHT NOW. IT WOULD ENFORCEMENT IT WOULD EVERY ENFORCEMENT ACTION BY THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'D LIKE TO BE OUT AS A CO SPONSOR. THANK YOU. UH COUNCIL WE ARE YOU BACK IN CU. OK, GOT IT, OK? I SEE NO ONE ELSE IN CU. UH, MADAM CLERK, PLEASE OPEN THE VOTING. COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN. YES. MR PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 22. YES VOTES AND THREE ABSTENTIONS. THANK YOU. THE ITEM IS ADOPTED. UM, MADAM CLERK, A READING OF

[32. O-023-24     ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LOUISVILLE/JEFFERSON COUNTY METRO GOVERNMENT CODE OF ORDINANCES (“LMCO”) CHAPTER 115 REGULATING POP UP PARTIES. 3/6/24 Public Safety Committee Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: Rick Blackwell (D-12) ]

ITEM 32. IN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LOWER JEFFERSON COUNTY METRO GOVERNMENT CODE OF ORDINANCES. L

[01:25:01]

MC O CHAPTER 115 REGULATING POP UP PARTIES READ IN FULL. COULD I GET A MOTION IN A SECOND? UH, MOTION BY COUNCILOR BAKER SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN SYME. IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION COUNCILMAN SANG. THANK YOU. MR PRESIDENT WAS TO REFER THIS TO COUNCILMAN BLACKWELL, PLEASE. COUNCILMAN BLACKWELL. THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. SO THIS ONE BE PRIOR. UH, TO PASSING THIS THE, UH, POP UP, UM, SECTIONS OF ACTUALLY FALL UNDER A CODE ENFORCEMENT INSTEAD OF ABC. UM SO THIS DOES A COUPLE OF THINGS IT CLARIFIES, UH, IF YOU'RE GONNA DO THE POP UP SITUATION WHERE YOU'RE GOING TO A RENTAL, AND YOU'RE GONNA SERVE ALCOHOL THERE, IT CLARIFIES WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO.

AND ESSENTIALLY, WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO IS WHAT EVERYONE ELSE HAS TO DO, WHICH IS GET A LICENSE IN ORDER TO DO THAT. UM AND THEN, UH, THE SECOND THING IS, IT CHANGES EVERY PLACE. CODE WHERE BEFORE CODE ENFORCEMENT WAS THAT WAS ONE MORE THING CODE ENFORCEMENT HAD TO DO. THIS PUTS IT UNDER ABC, WHICH MAKES IN MY MIND AT LEAST LOGICAL SENSE BECAUSE IT IS AN ABC ISSUE.

APPRECIATE IT. YES, THANK YOU. UH, IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION, COUNCILMAN HAWKINS? I'LL BE ABSTAINING FROM THIS AS WELL, UH, BUSINESS OWNER AN EVENT SPACE. UM I NEVER KNOW WHAT CAPACITY THAT, UM, A PERSON IS GOING TO RENT MY EVENT SPACE OUT FOR, UM, SO JUST FOR AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, UM, I DID SPEAK ON THIS AGAIN. UM FOR TRANSPARENCY, UM, IN COMMUNITY, SO JUST GIVE ME A LITTLE GRACE, UM AND I WOULD BE ABSTAINING. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR KRENN. I LIKE BEING AS A SPONSOR, IF YOU DON'T MIND. UH, COLLEAGUES. I DON'T SEE ANYBODY ELSE IN QUEUE.

COUNCILMAN FLOOD WOULD LIKE TO BE ADDED AS A SPONSOR. UH, DO WE OK, IT'S I'M NOT ON THE WRONG ITEM BECAUSE I HAD COUNCILMAN KRAMER, UM COUNCILWOMAN PURVIS. UH AND COUNCILWOMAN FLOOD. AND NOW I'VE GOT COUNCIL PERSSON AND BAKER. I LIKE TO BE AS A SPONSOR, PLEASE. AND COUNCILMAN BAKER. UH THANK YOU FOR THE WORK ON THIS. WE WOULD LOVE TO BE A COSPONSOR. NOW I DON'T SEE ANYBODY ELSE IN CUE. THIS IS AN ITEM REQUIRING A ROLL CALL. VOTE. MADAM CLERK. PLEASE OPEN THE VOTING. COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES. MR. PRESIDENT YOU HAVE 24? YES VOTES AND ONE ABSTENTION. THANK YOU. THE ITEM IS ADOPTED. UH, MADAM CLERK, A READING OF ITEM 33.

[33. CIF030524PW09     APPROPRIATING [$529.35] $57,000 FROM DISTRICT 9 CAPITAL INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDS TO PUBLIC WORKS FOR THE BICKEL ROAD SIDEWALK CONNECTOR PROJECT. 3/5/24 Labor, Economic Development, and Appropriations Committee  Approved; Correction Required Sponsors: Andrew Owen (D-9) ]

APPROPRIATING $57,000 FROM DISTRICT NINE CAPITAL INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDS TO PUBLIC WORKS FOR THE BICKLE ROAD, SIDEWALK CONNECTOR PROJECT. RED INFO, UH, MOTION BY COUNCILOR EL SECOND BY COUNCILOR PERISH WRIGHT. UH, IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION, COUNCILWOMAN PURVIS NO, SIR. OR I'M SORRY. THIS CAN I APOLOGIZE. THIS CAME FROM, UM UH, LABOR AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. COUNCILMAN BAKER. THANK YOU. I APOLOGIZE. I THOUGHT IT WAS A PUBLIC WORKS PROJECT. YOU ARE. YOU ARE COMPLETELY FINE. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. THIS UH, IS IN DISTRICT NINE, AND THE COUNCILMAN OWEN IS HERE TO SPEAK TO THIS. THIS IS SIMPLY A CLERICAL ERROR THAT WAS MADE. I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE THEM. CHARGE ME $529.35 A WORLD. IN FACT, IT IS A $57,000 PROJECT.

IT'S PRETTY COOL. WE'RE CONNECTING, UH, CRESCENT SPRINGS CONDOMINIUMS, WHICH IS AT THE BOTTOM OF BICKEL ROAD TO BASICALLY ALL OF THE OTHER NE, UH, SIDEWALK NETWORK IN IN CLIFTON, AND THERE ARE QUITE A FEW VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE THAT LIVE THERE WHO HAVE BEFORE NOW HAVE HAD TO WALK UP NICKEL ROAD KIND OF IN THE MIDDLE OF THE STREET. SO, UH, HAPPY MAKE THAT CONNECTION FROM THOSE CONDOMINIUMS AND THOSE HOUSES TO OUR SIDEWALK NETWORK. I APPRECIATE A VOTE. YES, ON THIS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION SEEING NONE? THIS IS AN ITEM REQUIRING A ROLL CALL. VOTE MADAM CLERK OR ACTUALLY, I'M SORRY. UH, IT'S AC IF. SO IT ACTUALLY ALLOWS FOR A VOICE VOTE BECAUSE WE'RE JUST MAKING THE CORRECTION ALL THOSE IN FAVOR. SAY AYE, I ANY OPPOSED THE AYES HAVE IT? MADAM CLERK ARE READING ABOUT HIM. 34. IN ORDER TO APPROPRIATING $7500 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER

[34. O-038-24     AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING $5,000 $7,500 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER: $5,000 FROM DISTRICT 13; AND $500 EACH FROM DISTRICTS 5, 10, 22, 24, AND 25; THROUGH THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET, TO THE PRISONER’S HOPE, INC. FOR FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF FAMILIES OF INCARCERATED OR FORMERLY INCARCERATED INDIVIDUALS IN JEFFERSON COUNTY (AS AMENDED). 3/5/24 Labor, Economic Development, and Appropriations Committee  Amended; Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: Dan Seum, Jr. (R-13), Donna L. Purvis (D-5), Pat Mulvihill (D-10), Robin Engel (R-22), Madonna Flood (D-24), Khalil Batshon (R-25)]

$5000 FROM DIFFERENT DISTRICT, 13 AND $500 EACH FROM DISTRICTS 5, 1022, 24 AND 25 THROUGH THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET TO THE PRISONERS HOPE AIMED FOR FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF FAMILIES OF INCARCERATED OR FORMERLY INCARCERATED INDIVIDUALS IN JEFFERSON COUNTY, AS AMENDED, READ IN FULL THANK YOU. MAY I GET A MOTION IN THE SECOND MOTION? I GET OWEN SECOND BY COUNCILOR BE SEAN. UH, THE PRO ITEM HAS BEEN PROBABLY MOVED AND SECONDED. IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION COUNCILMAN BAKER. THANK YOU. THIS IS, UM AN ORDINANCE THAT IS IN COUNCILMAN, UH, DISTRICT AND SO I WOULD LOVE TO DEFER TO CUSTOMER TYPE COUNCILMAN TIME. THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT. UM THE ASK HERE IS 20,000. WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO ACHIEVE 7500 THIS ORDINANCE FOR

[01:30:01]

A PRISONERS HOPE HELPS PRISONERS , MEN AND WOMEN WHO ARE CURRENTLY DOING TIME HELPS THEIR CHILDREN WHILE THEY'RE DOING TIME AND WHEN THEY GET OUT, IT HELPS THEM TO REINTEGRATE BACK INTO SOCIETY. IT HELPS THEM TO BILLS. GETTING TO APPOINTMENTS HELPS THEM WITH TRANSPORTATION.

UM IT'S A WORTHY ORGANIZATION. I VETTED IT THOROUGHLY. I'M ASKING FOR YOUR HELP TO MEET THE NEEDS.

PLEASE THANK YOU. 1000 FROM 17, PLEASE. DO YOU SEE THE COUNCILMAN BENSON? UH, I GET $500. BE C. HAS ANYBODY? UH, COUNCILMAN PARISH, RIGHT? UM, FINALLY SOMETHING COUNCILMAN SIMON AND I CAN WORK ON TOGETHER . I WOULD LIKE TO ADD 1000 TO THIS, PLEASE. THANK YOU, UH, COUNCILWOMAN HAWKINS, 1500 DISTRICT ONE, OK? UH, ANYBODY ELSE? COUNCILMAN, UH RENO WEBER.

IQ IS EMPTY. YOU. COUNCILOR MARINO WEBER. 500 FOR DISTRICT EIGHT. THE ITEM. UH I WAS ON THERE, UH, COUNCILMAN ARTHUR 500 DISTRICT FOUR. 500. THAT WAS OK. UH THANK YOU, COUNCILWOMAN CHAPPELL, UH, COUNCILMAN OWEN. 500 DISTRICT NINE, PLEASE. THANK YOU, COUNCILOR REED. UH, WANT TO, UH, THANK UH. COUNCILMAN SIMON FOR HIS WORK ON THIS, UH, I WORK FOR A COMPANY THAT ALSO PROVIDES SECOND CHANCE OPPORTUNITIES, SO I'M VERY HAPPY TO CONTRIBUTE. $750 DISTRICT 16.

THANK YOU, UH, COUNCILMAN CHAPEL OR I'M SORRY. COUNCILMAN RENO WEBER. ALREADY GOT A COUNCILMAN CHAPPELL 500 FROM DISTRICT 15. UH COUNCILWOMAN RUI 1000 FROM DISTRICT 21. YOU, COUNCILMAN P ARGENTI. 500 FROM DISTRICT 19, PLEASE. UH, THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN BLACKWELL. 500 DISTRICT 12, PLEASE. THANK YOU, UH, ANYBODY. COUNCILMAN SHANKLIN? 500 FROM DISTRICT TWO.

YOU. COLLEAGUES THAT PUTS US AT 16,750. ANYBODY ELSE ARE YOU BACK IN QUEUE? COUNCIL COUNCILOR PER RIGHT. YEAH I DON'T KNOW IF I CAN ADD BE ADDED AS A COSPONSOR, BUT I'LL ADD ANOTHER 500 TO THE 1000. OK? OK? ANYONE ELSE? SO THAT MAKES THE NEW TOTAL 17 COUNCILMAN PURPOSES.

I'VE ALREADY GIVEN, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO BE ADDED AS A SPONSOR. GOING ONCE. OK, COULD I GET AN AMENDMENT FOR SOME? I'M SORRY, COUNCILOR MCCRANEY. DID YOU OK? COULD I GET A MOTION FOR THE NEW AMOUNT 7250 MOTION BY COUNCILMAN PENTTI SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN S ANY DISCUSSION ON THE AMENDMENT HEARING? NONE. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE, I AND HE OPPOSED THE EYES HAVE IT. THE AMENDED ORDINANCE IS BEFORE US, UH, IT REQUIRES A ROLL CALL VOTE, OR IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION? HEARING.

NONE REQUIRES A ROLL CALL. VOTE, MADAM CLERK. PLEASE OPEN THE VOTING. COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES. COUNCIL MEMBER RENA WE. MR PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 25? YES, VOTES. THANK YOU. THE ITEM PASSES. MADAM CLERK ARE READING OF ITEM 35. AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING $10,000 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER $2500 FROM DISTRICT 21 $2000 FROM DISTRICT 15 $1500 IN DISTRICT 3 $1000 EACH FROM DISTRICTS EIGHT AND NINE AND $500 EACH FROM

[35. O-046-24     AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING $4,500 $10,000 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER: $2,500 FROM DISTRICT 21; AND $2,000 FROM DISTRICT 15; $1,500 FROM DISTRICT 3; $1,000 EACH FROM DISTRICTS 8 AND 9; AND $500 EACH FROM DISTRICTS 6, 10, 12, AND 24; THROUGH THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET, TO SOUTH LOUISVILLE COMMUNITY MINISTRIES, INC. FOR EVENT COSTS FOR THEIR ANNUAL FAMILIES HELPING FAMILIES FUNDRAISER EVENT (AS AMENDED). 3/5/24 Labor, Economic Development, and Appropriations Committee  Amended; Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: Betsy Ruhe (D-21), Jennifer Chappell (D-15), Shameka Parrish-Wright (D-3), Ben Reno-Weber (D-8), Andrew Owen (D-9), Phillip T. Baker (D-6), Pat Mulvihill (D-10), Rick Blackwell (D-12), Madonna Flood (D-24)]

DISTRICT 6, 1012 AND 24 THROUGH THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET TO SOUTH LOUIS COMMUNITY MINISTRIES INC FOR E EVENT COST FOR THEIR ANNUAL FAMILY HELPING FAMILIES FUNDRAISER EVENT AS AMENDED, READ IN FULL THANK YOU. MOTION BY COUNCILOR DE ARGENTI SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN ARTHUR.

IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION? COUNCILMAN BAKER? THIS IS ANOTHER ORDINANCE THAT'S IN COUNCILMAN SYMES DISTRICT, AND SO WOULD LIKE TO DEFER TO HIM. COUNCILMAN TAN OR NO. IT'S COUNCILMAN RIO I BELIEVE, AND COUNCILMAN CHAPPELL. SORRY WAS ON THE WRONG I LIKE THE DEER THEM SO COUNCILOR RUBBY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, UH, SOUTH, LOCAL COMMUNITY MINISTERS DOES A WHOLE LOT OF GOOD FOR OUR COMMUNITY. THEY WERE INSTRUMENTAL IN THE EVICTION PREVENTION PROGRAM DURING COVID, AND I'M VERY HAPPY TO SAY THAT THIS IS FULLY FUNDED AND WE DON'T NEED TO PASS THE HAT. THANK YOU. UH, WELL, EXCELLENT. WELL, ANY OTHER DISCUSSION? HEARING NONE. THIS IS AN ORDINANCE REQUIRING A ROLL CALL. VOTE MADAM CLERK, PLEASE OPEN THE I'M SORRY, COUNCILOR PI. I APOLOGIZE. I CLOSED MY WINDOW TOO QUICKLY. YOU WERE RIGHT. I THOUGHT I WAS ALREADY LISTED AS A COSPONSOR. BUT I DON'T KNOW YOU ARE A MAN FOR $1500. THANK YOU. COUNCIL MEMBER SHANKLIN, UH, CAN YOU OPEN THE VOTING? NEVER MIND. I'M GONNA THANK YOU, MA'AM. I REMEMBER FIVE. COUNCIL MEMBER BENSON. MR PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 25? YES VOTES. THANK YOU. THE ITEM IS

[01:35:18]

ADOPTED. MADAM CLERK ARE READING OF ITEM 36, A RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION NUMBER 067

[36. R-022-24     A RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 67, SERIES 2023, REGARDING THE GRANTING OF LOCAL INCENTIVES TO UNITED PARCEL SERVICE CO. (“UPS”) AND ANY SUBSEQUENT ASSIGNEES OR APPROVED AFFILIATES THEREOF PURSUANT TO KRS CHAPTER 154, SUBCHAPTER 32 TO DELETE A SENTENCE REGARDING THE STATE TO LOCAL PARTICIPATION RATIO AND TO CHANGE THE NAME OF THE COMPANY RECEIVING THE INCENTIVES FROM UPS TO UNITED PARCEL SERVICE CO. (AIR). 3/5/24 Labor, Economic Development, and Appropriations Committee  Recommended for Approval Action Required By: August 2024 Sponsors: Phillip T. Baker (D-6) ]

SERIES 2023 REGARDING THE GRANTING OF LOCAL INCENTIVES TO UNITED PARCEL SERVICE COMPANY UPS AND ANY SUBSEQUENT ASSIGNEE OR APPROVED AFFILIATES THEREOF, OR THEY'RE PURSUANT TO KRS CHAPTER 154 SUB CHAPTER 32 TO DELETE A SENTENCE REGARDING THE STATE TO LOCAL PARTICIPATION RATIO AND TO CHANGE THE NAME OF THE RECEIVING THE INCENTIVES FROM UPS TO UNITED PARCEL SERVICE COMPANY AIR RED IN FULL MOTION MOTION BY COUNCILOR ENGEL SECONDED BY COUNCILOR PIERINI.

IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION? COUNCILMAN BAKER YES, THIS IS, UH, A, UM, COUNCILWOMAN HAWKINS IS A SPONSOR ON THIS, AND SO SHE I'M GONNA DEFER, UH, WHY AM I ON THE WRONG IT'S JUST OUR EXTENSION. IT'S JUST. I GOT YOU. SORRY NOW WE'RE ON ON BOARD. APOLOGIZE OK? UM YES. UH I'M ACTUALLY THE COSPONSOR AND THIS IS JUST A CHANGE. THIS IS JUST A CHANGE SMALL LANGUAGE, AND I'M GOING TO ABSTAIN. OK WE HAVE A COUPLE OF ABSTENTIONS IN THIS. THANK YOU. OK? THANK YOU, UM COLLEAGUES. I NEED TO ABSTAIN BECAUSE I WORK FOR A COMPETITOR, COUNCILMAN BLACKWELL. YES I WILL ALSO BE ABSTAINING, UH, OUT OF ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION. MY WIFE IS AN EMPLOYEE OF UPS PROUD TEAMSTER. OK, THANK YOU IS THERE ANY OTHER DISCUSSION? UH, COUNCILMAN ARTHUR I MUST STAY TO MY GRANNY WORKS OVER HERE. SO I UH, IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION HEARING? NONE THIS IS AN ITEM. IT'S A RESOLUTION THAT REQUIRE THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR A VOICE VOTE. BUT IN ORDER TO RECORD THE ABSTENTIONS WE NEED TO CALL ROLL CALL VOTE, MADAM CLERK. COUNCIL MEMBER, SHANKLIN YES. COUNCIL MEMBER RENA WEBER. MR PRESIDENT. UH, COUNCIL MEMBER RE OK? COUNCILMAN ANGLE. I MY APOLOGY. ACTUALLY MY SON WORKED. MY SON WORKS FOR UP SI PROBABLY SHOULD ABSTAIN TOO. I'VE NEVER EVEN THOUGHT ABOUT IT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. SO NOTED, MISTER PRESIDENT, YOU HAVE 20 YES VOTES AND FOR ABSTENTIONS, THE ITEM IS ADOPTED. UH, MADAM CLERK OR READING OF ITEM 37. A RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO THE CAPITAL AND OPERATING BUDGET ORDINANCE TO APPROVE THE APPROPRIATION TO FUND THE FOLLOWING NONCOMPETITIVE NEGOTIATED SOLE SOURCE. CONTRACT FOR AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT A P CD CONCERNING AIR MONITORING EQUIPMENT TELE INC. $91,960 AS

[37. R-011-24     A RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO THE CAPITAL AND OPERATING BUDGET ORDINANCES APPROVING THE APPROPRIATION TO FUND THE FOLLOWING NONCOMPETITIVELY NEGOTIATED SOLE SOURCE CONTRACT FOR AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT (“APCD”) CONCERNING AIR MONITORING EQUIPMENT (TELEDYNE, INC - $91,960.00) (AS AMENDED). 3/7/24  Parks and Sustainability Committee  Amended;  Recommended for Approval Action Required By;  August 2024 Sponsors: Tammy Hawkins (D-1), Jecorey Arthur (I-4)]

AMENDED, READ IN FULL UH, MOTION BY COUNCILMAN SYMES SECONDED BY COUNCILMAN P ARGENTI. IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION, COUNCILMAN PARKER? YEAH. THE A PC. I BELIEVE I BELIEVE IT'S ON OLD BED. I BELIEVE THIS ITEM IS IN A BUSINESS, BUT IT WAS YOU AND I DON'T THINK THERE THERE WAS ANYTHING CONTENTIOUS ABOUT IT. CORRECT. I BELIEVE IT'S ON OUR BUSINESS BECAUSE IT WAS AMENDED IN COMMITTEE. UH, YES. IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION? COUNCILMAN UH, COUNCILMAN BAKER.

UH, THIS AFFECTS THE AQUA NEIGHBORHOOD AND SO I WOULD LOVE I JUST LOVE TO BE A CO CO SPONSOR ON THIS. THANK YOU. I'M SORRY. I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON. WE'VE HAD A CRAZY NIGHT. I AM SO SORRY. AND SO I JUST WANTED TO MAKE ALL MY COLLEAGUES LAUGH TODAY SO, BUT I WOULD LOVE TO BE A COSPONSOR ON THIS. OK SO NOTED, UH, COLLEAGUES. IS THERE ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION? UH, HEARING NONE. THIS IS A RESOLUTION THAT ALLOWS FOR A VOICE VOTE. ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY AYE, I AND HE OPPOSED THE EYES, HAVE IT. YES GOOD. UH COUNCILOR BAKER. GOOD NEWS. THE NEXT ITEM OF BUSINESS IS NEW BUSINESS. UH, COLLEAGUES. AS YOU LEAVE CHAMBERS, PLEASE DO SO

[New Business]

QUIETLY, SO THE CLERK MAY READ NEW BUSINESS. I WOULD ASK THOSE COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT WISH TO MAKE ANNOUNCEMENTS. PLEASE REMAIN IN THE CHAMBERS AND REQUEST TO SPEAK ON YOUR SYSTEM AND UNDER ANNOUNCEMENTS. NEW BUSINESS COMPRISES ITEMS 38 TO 53 WILL THE CLERK PLEASE READ THOSE ITEMS IN THEIR ASSIGNMENT TO A COMMITTEE? THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS ASSIGNED TO THE COMMITTEE ON COMMITTEES ITEM 38. A RESOLUTION OF THE LOUISVILLE METRO COUNCIL, AMENDING THE

[01:40:03]

METRO COUNCIL EMPLOYEE HANDBOOK TO UPDATE THE PARENTAL LEAVE POLICY. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS ASSIGNED TO EQUITY COMMUNITY AFFAIRS, HOUSING, HEALTH AND EDUCATION COMMITTEE ITEM 39 A RESOLUTION HONORING THE LIFE AND LEGACY OF MARVIN HART BY DEDICATING THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF WEST MUHAMMAD ALI BOULEVARD IN FIRST STREET AS MARMON HART WHITE IN HIS HONOR ITEM, 40, A RESOLUTION HONORING THE LIFE AND LEGACY OF GREGORY P. BY DEDICATING THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF WEST MUHAMMAD ALI BOULEVARD IN SECOND STREET AS GREGORY PAGE IN HIS HONOR ITEM 41 AND A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT $19,000 OF FUNDING FROM THE NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ASSOCIATION THROUGH THE RETAIL, FLEXIBLE FUNDING MODEL, OR GRANT PROGRAM TO THE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELLNESS ITEM. 42 RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT $100,000 OF FUNDING FROM THE US CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION. THE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND LABORATORY CAPACITY ELC GRANT PROGRAM, TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELLNESS. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS ASSIGNED TO LABOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE ITEM. 43 AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING $5900 FROM NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS IN THE FOLLOWING MANNER 3000 FROM DISTRICT 9 1000 FROM DISTRICT 24 650 FROM DISTRICT 3 500 EACH FROM DISTRICTS EIGHT AND 21 AND $250 FROM DISTRICT 13. THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET, CRESCENT HILL COMMUNITY COUNCIL INC FOR PRIVATE SECURITY COSTS FOR THE FRANKFURT AVENUE EASTER PARADE. ITEM 44 IN THE ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING 6 $5500 FROM THE DISTRICT SIX NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS TO METRO PARKS FOR COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE ANNUAL JAZZ IN CENTRAL PARK EVENT ITEM 45 AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING WITH $10,000 FROM DISTRICT SIX NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT FUNDS TO THE LOW, METRO POLICE DEPARTMENT, FOURTH DIVISION TO FUND OVERTIME FOR ADDITIONAL PARK PATROLLING OF THE OLD LOUISVILLE IN LIMERICK NEIGHBORHOODS ITEM 46 RESOLUTION APPROVING THE GRANTING OF LOCAL INCENTIVES TO CHEMICAL AND INDUSTRIAL ENGINEER INK AND ANY SUBSEQUENT ASSIGNEE OR APPROVED AFFILIATES, THEREFORE, PURSUANT TO KRS CHAPTER 154 AND SUBCHAPTER T 32. THE FOLLOWING LEGISLATION WAS ASSIGNED TO PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE ITEM 47 AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE ZONING OF PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 141 AND 143 EAST WOODLAWN AVENUE CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY 0.28 ACRES AND BEING IN LOUISVILLE. METRO CASE NUMBER 23 ZONE 0142 ITEM 48 OR RELATING TO THE ZONING OF PROPERTY LOOKING AT 76 01 MILL ROAD CONTAINING A 2.66 ACRES AND B IN LOUISVILLE.

METRO CASE NUMBER 23 ZONE 0058 ITEM 49 AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE CLOSURE OF UNIMPROVED PORTION OF ALI AND ADJACENT TO WHAT 1317 AND 1319 TILE FACTORY LANE CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY 12,813 SQUARE FEET AND BEING IN LOUISVILLE. METRO CASE NUMBER 23 STR CLOSURE 0039 ITEM 50 AN ORDINANCE RELATING TO THE REVISED DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR PROPER AT OLD HE ROOM PORTIONS OF PARCEL ID NUMBER 0047029300 AND 00470294000 CON CONTINUE APPROXIMATELY 6.54 ACRES AND BEING IN LOUISVILLE METRO CASE NUMBER 20 3D DP 0116 ITEM 51 A RESOLUTION UPDATING THE STANDARD DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR LANDMARKS. THE VOTING LEGISLATION WAS ASSIGNED TO PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ITEM 52 A RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY SENATE BILL 13 TO ALLOW THE COMMONWEALTH TO ACT EXPEDITIOUSLY IN THE INTEREST OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND WELFARE. THE FOLLOWING DECISION WAS ASSIGNED TO PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE ITEM 53 OF RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT UP TO $80,000 OF FUNDING FROM THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY. KENTUCKY'S TRANSPORTATION CABINET TOURED THE BRIDGE REPAIRS AT GOLDSMITH LANE PROJECT TO BE ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND ASSETS. READ IN FULL.

[Announcements]

THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE ANNOUNCEMENTS IN THE ANNOUNCEMENTS. HEARING NONE THAT CONCLUDES OUR MEETING. OUR NEXT COUNCIL MEETING IS SCHEDULED FOR THURSDAY. APRIL 11TH 2024 AT 6

[Adjournment]

P.M. WITH NO FURTHER BUSINESS TO DISCUSS WITHOUT OBJECTION. ADJOURNED. THIS POINT UP HERE, TOO.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.